Here's the thing.

I have spent 4 years working in and on crypto.

When I criticise it, I know what I'm talking about.

I was drawn in by the idea of a new financial system that didn't rely on traditional banks. I was excited by the idea of rebuilding digital ownership in a post-streaming world.

In the end, I came to realise my idealism had blinded me. The philosophy was largely false.

And outweighed by the scams, thefts, fraud and grift.

Crypto cost me my life's savings from theft and scams.

It cost me the last of my optimism when I realised the vast majority of people who claimed to support me as a creator were speculators who turned on me, threatened me and harassed me when they realised my work wasn't designed to be an "asset"

I believe in decentralisation. But right now - that's not what crypto is building. It's almost entirely a wealth generation scheme.

@Daojoan

I’m so sorry for your loss. You’re doing a real service by sharing your story now.

#CryptoIsBullshit #GetRobbed

@Daojoan

Sorry to hear you got snookered. I remember telling a young woman several years ago that crypto was a Ponzi scheme, and she just told me how much her crypto had gone up in value since she bought it. I don’t know how she’s doing these days though.

@Daojoan it has been an interesting socioeconomic experiment. Experiments fail sometimes. Too bad that this one involves hundreds of billion dollars already. Also, quite an impact on the global environment.

One lesson definitely learnt: don't try building an independent currency. It's going to be a huge and nasty mess.

@Daojoan I'm curious, in what way were they seeing your work as an asset? I'm ignorant, so I'm genuinely curious. What were they hoping to gain from your work, and how were they hoping to gain it?
@nathan @Daojoan It is stock market mentality: they buy art at €X with the intent to sell it at €10X a year later, but not for enjoyment.

@Daojoan how does DeFi support the little people? DeFi will never offer the protection to people that they enjoy under the CFPB and the myriad other financial regulators that ensure American banks are safe, secure, well capitalized, and when there is an issue ensure it is handled in an orderly manner with minimal disruption to depositors and debtors.

Bankers face strict limits on what they do, no such limits exist for the world of DeFi. There is no institution, just the jungle of the market

@Daojoan I don’t believe all cryptocurrencies and cryptocurrency-related projects are scams, but you’re right that almost all of them are scams or scam-adjacent. I hope that we eventually see the wheat separated from the chaff.

@Daojoan I'm sorry to learn about your losses in cryptocurrency.

I've worked with computers long enough that I've learned to approach new claims with skepticism.

Cryptocurrency seems like another Ponzi pyramid scheme--thosenl who profit do so only at the expense of newcomers, with no net generation of new value.

@Daojoan I lost a small sum thanks to e-gold many years ago.
@Daojoan I used to tell people I mined Bitcoin on a CPU when that was a reasonable thing to do, to make it clear I was dismissing crypto from a position of knowledge. But these days no one still pushing crypto even understands what that means. Scammers don't know and don't care about the tech. And, to be fair, the tech doesn't matter...it only works for crime.
@Daojoan So a Ponzi? I invested maybe 1 or 2% early on but think 5% is excessive.
@JonChevreau @Daojoan
Worse than a Ponzi; a Ponzi scheme just moves the money around, crapto actually burns a lot of it
@Daojoan it would be nice if more people were able to admit they were wrong about stuff like this. Thank you.

@Daojoan regulation on traditional securities is not the product of nanny state fascists. It represents the accumulated expertise of thousands of efforts reacting to fraud and exploitive behavior.

These ecoin tragedies are a feature not a bug. And that sucks. I'm sorry for your experience.

@jjlupa @Daojoan
That is the raison d'être of lots of 'disruptive' technologies/services, they are relying on legislation/regulation not catching up for some years and in that golden wild west period they destroy the traditional product/service they are 'disrupting'.
Out with crypto, things like Uber and Air b'n'b are now getting some serious regularity push back and may struggle in the long term if they haven't yet destroyed their original disruptee's.

@Daojoan

Lessons learned this way are very tough lessons. Reliable as rain, every few years the scammers figure out a new pump-and-dump bubble to transfer other people's money into their coffers. So very sorry you got caught up in one of these. Years ago the dot-com bubble blasted away a small fortune, and that was a tough lesson, but never again. Chasing tigers is a dangerous game. AI is next. Stay clear of that beast.

#PumpAndDump #Crypto #AI #Scam

@Daojoan It was a great idea, it really was, but as with so many other laudable ideas, it was hijacked by (I want to say people with bad intentions) people, normal people who saw the chance to make something from almost nothing. For a time, some of them did. After that it got dark, quickly, and now we're back to where we were in 2007. You know what, my mobile first bank today is way better than my giant back from 1990. Some things did get better.
@Daojoan I have never purchased any crypto related currency but I support the vision. I sincerely hope that it can find its footing and move beyond all the scams and fraud but I just don't know if it can.
@Daojoan Do you think there can be any redemption for it, or are the issues just inherent due to the anonymity the currency provides? Or would that require too much regulation?

@r00sty @Daojoan
To the extent there were real experiments to be run and real questions to be answered with blockchain-based currencies, they were all failures, all answered in the negative

At the very most, Silk Road, problematic as it was, operated unmolested for about two years, before earning someone double life plus forty; that's closest crapto ever came to anything anyone could call a success

One guy bought some pizza

Meanwhile, blockchain displaced all sorts of other distributed experiments, some quite promising, distributed LETS systems and the like; if there's to be redemption, it'll come from those, or from new ones

@Daojoan When I was introduced to Bitcoin, it was abundantly clear that the "philosophy" was *literally* indistinguishable from a mechanism for making it difficult to hold financial criminals accountable.. The simple fact that Satoshi Nakamoto was not available to testify under oath was enough to convince me.
@Daojoan are you an anticapitalist now?
@Daojoan Indeed rugs and scams are the big problem here, but I still believe we can find a way out. Recently I've been working with a team which is focusing on the governance of tokenomics and dApps, and we have submitted a project grants application to Ethereum Foundation. Wish we can make it- to build a well-governed crypto world!
@Daojoan a lot of the responses to this post are about whether crypto is good or bad, but there's a human element you are sharing here and I just want to say I appreciate you do so.
@Daojoan Some of us who have researched governance and risk management could tell that it was a scam a mile away. Crypto is a scam, a very dark dangerous scam.

@Daojoan if something promises wealth, there always appears a strange species.

The more they eat, the hungrier they get. Unsatiable.

Kimmerer calls it Windigo economy in her book braiding sweetgrass.

I must admit I never had the brain capacity to understand cryptos. I hope you can compensate your financial loss.

@Daojoan I know the technology very well. Whenever I criticise cryptocurrencies, someone will try to "explain to me what I'm not getting". And they never counter what I said, they always just sidestep and rave about something else.
@Daojoan I appreciate this honest review of crypto, I've been halting alot when it comes to it... so I'll stick to sickening monthly bank charges for awhile... Thanks again...