Based on everything I’ve heard of it, this seems a bit too high.

It’s not. I personally love the game, but it has a lot of flaws and that number seems about right to me. I think it’s a better game than Fallout 4.

Some of the storylines are fantastic, but they’re pretty disjointed from the rest of the world. Some of them feel like they have loose ends that didn’t get finished in time.

There are several game systems that are neat, but unfinished, and superfluous.

I really don’t understand the dog pile this game has gotten.

Totally agree. People are supremely critical of this game, I think it’s because it had so much hype. I have a friend that played 70 hours and he said it’s a 4 or 5 out of 10. Come on, when was the last time you played a 4 for 70 hours. A 6 or 7 sure, but you played and talked about the game non-stop for 3 weeks. Talking about how you didn’t want to work, just wanted to play all day. A 4 does not do that to you.