For me, right to to repair isn't just about ewaste, and preventing corporate gouging.

It's about mental health. Being able to fix your gadgets is therapeutic. Empowering. Good for the soul.

In a world full of complex technology it's easy to feel small and helpless. And maybe I'm too much of an idealist, but I think that if everyone could experience the joy of fixing or modifying a gadget now and then we'd all be a little more open minded, a little more daring. A little harder to push around.

@futurebird There's also a nesting/nostalgia element to it. Objects you've mended and repaired become familiar and loved. In a disposable culture, your possessions are constantly changing, as if you're adrift in a sea of materialism. There's something lovely about the well known and well worn object.
@dx @futurebird I wrote a university thesis about this and spent 8000 words to say it badly. You managed to say it better in two 500ch (?) posts. Thank you.
@qwazix @dx @futurebird
I'd have a look at that
@qwazix
Same as above, don’t suppose the thesis exists online somewhere? Such a virtuous cycle, that #eufficiency - human joy and empowerment produced, material value and resources conserved.
@SarraceniaWilds @dx @futurebird
@cwicseolfor I can send it to you, but it's in Greek. I'd like to translate it at some point, but after submitting it I wanted some time off
@qwazix Anyone who has the tenacity to get through a thesis deserves a few years of rest, whether or not that can happen in practice. Unfortunately not one of my languages (...yet...) but if you translate it anytime going forward I can pretty safely say I won't have lost interest in the subject. Following!
(Since @SarraceniaWilds asked first - I don't suppose you read Greek?)
@SarraceniaWilds I'm sorry, this one never federated to me, I just realized when @dx said you asked first. I'll keep you posted with a translation, now that I know someone would take a look, I have much more incentive to translate.
@qwazix @dx No worries, and dont rush on our account. What sounds like a fun time to us is probably weeks of work for you 😅
@futurebird so true. We had a TV die a little over 18 months after purchase (days after the warranty expired). It happened on New Year's Eve. The following day, we went to Radio Shack and bought the supplies to replace the capacitors that had swollen on the power supply. It was incredibly empowering (no pun intended) to be able to feel like we had some say. The class action lawsuit and free repairs came years later, probably too late for most people.

@prettymuch

@futurebird

When I was around 9 yo, our TV had vacuum tubes.

We had an ironmonger's (hardware store) on the next street, just a tiny place in row housing.

It had replacement tubes (valves, we called them), and we'd need one once a year.

My dad was a mechanic. He taught me to fix cars.

I've rebuilt engines, but I look under the hood in mine and wouldn't dare start.

@futurebird the first time I fixed something that was breaking (breaking solder in my small mp3-player jack) I was really elated - and whatever you fix and works again is more valuable to you afterwards, there are only upsides
@mmby @futurebird I have an early 2000s HP Laserjet printer where the circuit board was printed with early non-lead solder, and it tended to die of cracks within a couple years, but I baked the board it in my oven a couple of times according to someone's online recommendations and it has been fixed for a decade and a half now.
@mmby @futurebird Helped a friend with his old audiophile stereo that turned out to have a failed op-amp, had one of those rip-van-winkle electronics moments when I realized that the specs on the new cheap-generic op-amps kicked the shit out of the old specialty "audiophile" op-amp.
@futurebird It does feel good. I repaired a couple of old computer keyboards earlier this year (IBM model Ms we've been using for decades) and the feeling of satisfaction from the whole thing is difficult to overstate.
@futurebird Thanks for articulating this. I’m a fixer, too. Partly because I’m cheap, but also because it’s so satisfying.
@futurebird When I was a kid, my dad (who grew up during the Great Depression) would always order schematics from HW Sam's when he bought an appliance. He keeps appliances working around the house for decades (like the microwave he got 50 year's use out of).
@futurebird Why I've always preferred to build my own computer and use Android phones. If I can't tinker what's the point? Learned helplessness is what they want
@futurebird hell yeah! I love this reason
@futurebird Having worked in northern and remote locations, right to repair is a game changer for people (frustration of losing your gadget for extended period) and business (frustration and revenue loss when losing your essential technology for extended periods).

@futurebird

And if you’re not going to fix it yourself, having the quiet guy with his little repair shop in the old service station or the funny woman with cool hair in the basement shop under the sandwich place is a public good whether you need something repaired or not. Those places existing are good for a community’s ephemeral spirit.

@MichaelTBacon

In "New York Cities Hypogeographies" (the novel I've been working on for two years) the old woman who runs the repair shop is the connection that unites the robots who are having a revolution and the people of Deep Brooklyn who are oppressed in less obvious ways by the Distributed Prison. She helps families to locate the pods of inmates and free them, and is one of the few human people aware what is really going on at the lower margin of the excavations.

@MichaelTBacon @futurebird we have a monthly mostly-free repair-a-thon in the church hall in my inner city community.

@futurebird

Have you read "Unauthorized bread"?

https://www.defectivebydesign.org/blog/doctorows_novella_unauthorized_bread_explains_why_we_have_fight_drm_today_avoid_grim_future

More focused on DRM than repairability, but modifying your devices as an act of joyful power made me think of it.

Doctorow's novella "Unauthorized Bread" explains why we have to fight DRM today to avoid a grim future | Defective by Design

@futurebird My fave childhood confidence building memories are from learning how to repair all sorts of things, with my Dad.
@futurebird Absolutely! Fixing our own gadgets is empowering and therapeutic. In our tech-driven world, it’s a small act of rebellion and self-reliance. 🛠️🔧 #RightToRepair
@futurebird I get this. It's intimacy with what's around you.
@futurebird we'll be unstoppable when we realize the "angry white male" is actually frustrated and helpless and yelling at his computer for not working or something like that metaphorically.
@futurebird totally. and even while some people may never become inclined to tinker themselves, if we were free to explore and transform our machines as we see fit, it would mean it shouldn't be too hard to find someone who can help you, and that builds up the chains of solidarity necessary to organize as a community.
@futurebird a fun youtube channel i found recently is https://www.youtube.com/@bigclivedotcom/videos he takes consumer electronics apart and explains how it works with circuit diagrams and all. and sometime suggests ways of hacking them
bigclivedotcom

The trashiest electronic channel on YouTube. We test and use affordable electronic soldering equipment and tools to build, teardown, modify (and sometimes destroy) random electronic stuff. A British TV licence is NOT required to view my videos or almost every other video on YouTube. Many of the builds and projects featured here operate at full mains voltage and carry a high risk of shock and fire. As such they're really intended for either entertainment value or for those who do similar stuff. The videos are generally uncensored and may contain tasteless jokes, profanities and even blood and electric shocks when things go wrong. So just like a normal workshop really. So kick back, grab a beer and enjoy the ride.

YouTube

@futurebird whether or not you’re an idealist aside, you’re also correct. In DBT, what you’re describing would fall under the broader category of “building mastery” (learning new skills in general also fall under that category), which is a useful tool for emotional regulation and creating positive experiences.

 

@futurebird @mekkaokereke So much this. Every time I’ve been able to fix a problem myself, either by following instructions or figuring it out myself, I’m left with both a solution and a sense of empowerment that I know will carry forward to the next time I’m faced with that sort of situation.
@futurebird It's also about the right to fix the phone after you buy it. Most phones come with so much bloatware you can't remove it's pointless to bother upgrading. Right to repair means I can wipe that garbage and install a thinner OS. One that isn't spying on everything I do and say in its vicinity.
@futurebird even for those who can't fix their stuff, there is a nice community aspect. It just feels nice to be able to bring your stuff to local tinkerer who loves to fix stuff (or to be that tinkerer, which is often my case)

@futurebird the right and ability to repair also gives important outs from the cycle of constant crises that comes with poverty.

So many of those crises boil down to 'an essential item broke (because it's low quality/second hand, because poverty), now I'm between a rock and a hard place: pay money or try to exist without it'.

@futurebird I completely agree. I'm not very technically skilled at all, but ever since I started hanging out with my boyfriend he started teaching me basic technical skills. I'm still not very good at it, but I'm at least not nearly as incompetent and ignorant as I once was and that's all I can really wish for.

@futurebird Preach!

Computers turning into walled-garden app-store-only consumer devices is one of my least favorite technology trends

@futurebird Yes! A hundred times "yes!".

@futurebird It's not just tech. How many people these days can thread a needle, stitch up a hem or replace a button? Make a loaf of bread from scratch? Plant a seed and nurture it into a plant, and on to fruition? Navigate by the stars?

We are losing all the skills that enabled our not so distant ancestors to survive. We are being nudged into a state of childish helplessness.

It's not a sustainable position for the human race.

@futurebird Right to Repair is required. It cost me over $100 for a repairman to walk in my door and say “It’s not worth fixing.”
@futurebird yes. Some of those of us who design and build these systems think that way.

@futurebird I suddenly hear Leah 'See Jane Drill' Bolden's "You can do this!" 🙂

My favorite recent one on the channel was https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dWNQoyPKhJE

Plumbers Charge $150 for this FIVE CENT repair

YouTube
@futurebird definitely agree, it brings down a few extra hurdles we don't need in our lives, and helps foster a community ready to fix problems together.

@futurebird

...I agree; in fact, I made a career out of fixing computers/printers.

@futurebird A couple of years ago my electric lawn mower battery died and the manufacturer no longer sold replacements. I took it apart and discovered it was two small 12v batteries hooked together. I bought new batteries, put everything back together, and my lawn mower was working like new. It was an amazing feeling to figure out how to fix it on my own.
@futurebird I don’t know I got 2 left hands what repairing belongs I probably make it worse
@futurebird haven't really repaired much, if anything, but seeing very similar things from creative hobbies that leave you with physical proof of your time and effort I believe you without a second thought.
@futurebird Actually I really miss that if something is no longer working you simply open the case to take a look inside. My dad always used to do this, from toaster to washing machine, from bike to car. Not being able to do that any more feels... unnatural.
@futurebird it's about agency in the digital world, plain and simple.

@futurebird

Wow yes.

Bet this is a part of the reason city mayors, the local lords of capitalism, come so hard against homeless encampments even when we're on the outskirts.

Every camp of unhoused people becomes a hotbed of scavenging and repair.

One of the best things that comes with the stability of the camp is fixing up your own stuff and own space.

#RightToRepair

@nearnorth @futurebird That's an interesting thought.

Broadly, I think the war on the unhoused is part of the long-running process to pin people people down in place to control them.

@nearnorth @futurebird I'm sure if they thought about it that would be part of their reasoning, but alas I strongly suspect it's because they (and conspiracy-minded homeowners) think that homeless people will "bring down property values" by being visibly poor.

@futurebird Empowering, that's the word.

Not having the right to repair is all about power. Corporations are in fact mafias flexing their (legal) power to force you to pay. It's a system designed to make you submit to them.

Racketeering. n. A type of organized crime in which the persons set up a coercive, fraudulent, extortionary, or otherwise illegal coordinated scheme or operation to repeatedly or consistently collect a profit.

Doesn't DRM for repairs fall exactly under the definition of racketeering? But they call it "business".

It's all about power, really.

@futurebird some stidies have also shown that copyrights and patents actually harm creativity and thereby cause economic losses, which is another good argument for repairability.