very interesting (though reformist!) essay in The Nation on Michigan, the MDOC, and the proposed Good Time Bill

Michigan’s Prison Crisis by Jacqueline Williams

https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/michigan-prison-good-time/

"Michigan has one of the longest average criminal sentence lengths in the country. The disparity is driven by several factors, one of the largest being that, since 1998, Michigan has been one of two states that provide no ability to earn time off a sentence: no disciplinary credits, no productivity credits, no 'good time.'

Michigan used to offer different forms of earned-time incentives, but a 1978 ballot initiative removed the majority of our 'good time' credits, and then the 1994 Crime Bill provided financial kickbacks for states that adopted 100 percent 'truth in sentencing'—a failed policy that requires people to serve every single moment of their original sentence, despite institutional behavior, achievements, and productive rehabilitation. This ushered in an era of mass incarceration in our state and throughout the country."

#Michigan #TruthInSentencing #GoodTimeBill

Michigan’s Prison Crisis

The state, often considered a bastion of progressive policies, has some of the worst carceral instincts and politics.

The Nation

it is true that this particular conglomeration of prison reforms has kept people behind bars for longer and longer, and that Truth In Sentencing in particular needs to be repealed, like, yesterday. Enthusiasm for the bill from outside organizers and prisoners alike shouldn't be diminished, but as we know, most prison reforms can and do create and maintain arbitrary and repressive distinctions between prisoners who "deserve" to be release and those who don't (the distinction between "non-violent" and "violent" offenders; "innocent/wrongfully convicted" versus, lol, not that; "good" and "bad" immigrants) -- and we know that Good Time could and would be barred for people, like our comrade Jonathan Summers, who are classified as "Security Threat Group" or STG.

read about Jonathan's skepticism about the Good Time Bill and his analysis of STG here: https://michiganabolition.org/2023/08/18/new-zine-from-inside-the-mdoc-stg-good-time-and-the-malicious-demons-of-coercion-by-jonathan-summers/

It is significant that the restoration of Good Time, on its own, has both been blocked by MI AG Dana Nessel, but that doesn't make the bill a panacea to the litany of problems that are present in the Nation article (let alone the ones that didn't make it in...)

#Michigan #TruthInSentencing #GoodTimeBill #STG #AbolitionNOW

New Zine from Inside the MDOC: “STG, Good Time, and the Malicious Demons of Coercion” by Jonathan Summers

MAPS is honored to present an essay submitted to us by Jonathan “Prynce-G” Summers, a comrade who is currently held captive at Chippewa Correctional Facility in the Upper Peninsula. In …

Michigan Abolition and Prisoner Solidarity

the article in the Nation focuses on hopelessness ("'There is nothing to do... So what do people do? Drugs. I’ve seen so many people develop addictions in here just trying to kill the time.' ... This isn’t good for the people incarcerated or the people working inside these facilities") and the prison as an unsafe working condition ("The union representing correctional officers has highlighted disastrous understaffing within state prisons, complete with stomach-churning quotes from MDOC staff about mandatory overtime and its effect on their lives and health") but not on the function of keeping Good Time off of the state books -- as Jonathan Summers told us, its to keep on warehousing racialized surplus populations.

There is certainly an overall crisis of liquidating and disappearing humans into Michigan's cages -- but is this a crisis of the MDOC? Or is this how the prison generally, and prisons in Michigan, meant to function? To warehouse people until they die? Keep in mind that a growing number of people locked up by the MDOC are over the age of 55 (source: https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2023/08/02/aging/)

The aging prison population: Causes, costs, and consequences

New Census Bureau data show the U.S. population is getting older — and at the same time, our prison populations are aging even faster. In ...

should the good time bill be passed? yes
is the way that the bill is talked about in both Michigan-based prisoner justice organizing circles kind of weird? also yes
is one reform going to be enough? obviously not -- Good Time being restored and Truth in Sentencing being repealed would do a tremendous amount to release prisoners and decrease the number of people warehoused

but let's be honest about what the MDOC and what warehousing racialized surplus populations allows the state to do -- it is a process of preserving and recalibrating political power (prison gerrymandering https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan-government/critics-say-prisons-give-rural-michigan-towns-unfair-edge-redistricting), it is the process of dispossessing and further waging domestic war on urban black populations in Michigan to rural white populations by transferring money, jobs, and power from places like Detroit to Ionia (for more, see our essay Containing the Crisis: https://michiganabolition.org/2017/11/16/containing-the-crisis/)

Critics say prisons give rural Michigan towns unfair edge in redistricting | Bridge Michigan

Advocates call it ‘prison gerrymandering’ and say urban cities are denied truly fair representation because inmates are counted as residents of their prisons. Others say it's not so simple.

the Good Time Bill does not face opposition because Dana Nessel does not know what it's like to be incarcerated (such a claim is presented in the aforementioned Nation piece: "Make no mistake, if every single prosecutor or elected official in the country woke up tomorrow in a prison cell and had to spend one week there, the prison system would be changed overnight"), but because it would undo the very processes that the prison regime in Michigan needs to keep itself afloat. the state opposition to this particular reform threatens the continuous churning of the gears of racial capitalism.

and, as this thread suggests, such a bill needs far more scrutiny for the ways it throws a bone to "good" prisoners who haven't gotten tickets, because the prison rebels and political prisoners would surely be shut out of such a reform. What's the call? Free them ALL.

a crisis for our communities is not necessarily a crisis for the state