Biden is quietly reversing Trump’s sabotage of Obamacare

https://lemmy.world/post/1383407

Biden is quietly reversing Trump’s sabotage of Obamacare - LemmyWorld

Slowly but surely, President Biden is repairing the U.S. health-care system, reversing Trump-era sabotage and ensuring millions more Americans get access to affordable coverage. The latest of these efforts came on Friday, in a little-noticed but significant decision to protect Americans from junk health insurance. In 2017, Congress repeatedly tried and failed to repeal the Affordable Care Act. To casual observers, it might have looked like the end of the Republican fight to kill this lifesaving, inequality-fighting, newly popular law. It wasn’t. Over the next few years, President Donald Trump found new ways to sabotage the health-care system and its protections for the most vulnerable Americans. Among the most insidious of these backdoor repeal measures: expanding “short-term, limited duration” health plans — i.e., attempting to trick Americans into plans that looked cheap but basically covered nothing. Short-term plans are theoretically intended as brief, stopgap coverage — say, to tide over a new college grad whose job doesn’t start until the fall. They’re relatively unregulated; they don’t have to cover minimum care benefits guaranteed by Obamacare and other major legislation, for example. A 2018 analysis found that most don’t cover maternity services, substance-abuse care or prescription drugs. These plans can also deny coverage for care of preexisting conditions, even if the preexisting condition in question hadn’t yet been diagnosed at the time the person enrolled. People often don’t realize they’ve bought a worthless product until it’s too late — when they get hit by a bus, say, or are diagnosed with a brain tumor. Such loopholes might seem like no big deal until you find yourself falling through one. The Trump administration made sure more people did by allowing these allegedly short-term plans to last as long as 364 days, rather than the three-month max that had been in place, and to be renewed for up to three years. This made them look a whole lot like regular plans. Plus, because short-term plans are mega-profitable for insurers, brokers can get much larger commissions for steering hapless customers into them. So, many did. Exactly how many were lured by this policy change is unclear; the data is lousy, precisely because these products are so unregulated. A recent estimate from the Urban Institute ballparked the number of people enrolled in individual plans that are noncompliant with Obamacare protections at 2.5 million. The proliferation of short-term junk plans affects even consumers who don’t get duped by them. That’s because these cheaper plans disproportionately siphon healthier (i.e., lower-cost) people out of the broader individual insurance marketplaces. People who have chronic conditions or otherwise know they will need more substantial coverage are more likely to stay in the regular marketplace pool, driving premiums there ever higher. Last week, however, the Biden administration announced a rollback of this Trump-era expansion of short-term health plans. In a proposed rule, Biden officials said those already in these skimpy Trump-blessed plans can continue in them, if they so choose. (“There were some hard lessons learned from the ‘if you like your plan you can keep it’ blowback a decade ago,” surmises Georgetown University health scholar Sabrina Corlette.) But going forward, any new “short-term, limited duration” plans would need to be truly short-term (up to three months) and truly limited-duration (renewed for up to one additional month only). Critically, short-term plans must also provide clearer language about what care they do and don’t cover, and under what circumstances. People who choose to buy junk must know upfront that they’re buying junk. The White House has marketed this rule as part of “Bidenomics,” though it might be more easily understood as simply pro-consumer. It also dovetails nicely with other actions the administration has taken to expand access to coverage, including outreach to encourage eligible Americans to enroll in marketplace plans and patching the so-called family glitch (a regulatory accident that had blocked a lot of families from accessing subsidized health coverage). Most important, through last summer’s Inflation Reduction Act, Biden extended the enhanced premium tax credits available for plans on the individual marketplace. This has meant that millions more Americans can get solid health-care coverage that not only is affordable but also, in many cases, has an out-of-pocket premium of zero dollars. And unlike with those junk insurance plans, the low price tag here isn’t a red flag; these plans actually do provide comprehensive coverage, including for people with preexisting conditions. It’s not a bait-and-switch. It’s a real subsidy — and one that will likely drive down premiums overall, on average, by drawing more healthy people into the broader marketplace risk pool. Our health-care system is still kludgy. It still allows too many Americans to fall through the cracks. But small unsung fixes such as this are achievements worth celebrating.

Holy shit, I lean pretty solid left, but damn this is some propaganda. I’ll start by saying that I truly believe that our country should provide universal healthcare, but the ACA ain’t it. I work in health insurance and the ACA plans have significantly more problems than any “junk” plans out there. Here’s a few examples from personal experience:

  • Inaccurate provider directory - ACA carriers may show a doctor/hospital as in network during the open enrollment period, then 3 or 4 months later when the person goes to use the plan they find out the directory was wrong. At that point, since we’re outside of the open enrollment period they are basically screwed and have to pay out of pocket to continue to use their preferred facilities.

  • Customer service - good luck getting someone from any ACA carrier on the phone. Any time there is an issue it’s a jerk around fest getting someone that has any ability to help whatsoever.

  • Network - Good luck trying to get coverage if you’re traveling out of state and have an accident or get sick and need to see a doctor. You just flat out can’t use it

  • Network part 2 - The vast majority of plans are either HMO or EPO. Let’s say you’re on an HMO and have a health condition where you need to see a specialist regularly. You need to go to your primary care for a referral EVERY SINGLE TIME you need to go to that specialist. With EPO’s you can skip that referral step, but good luck getting an appointment in any sort of reasonable timeframe. It usually takes 3-6 months to get in for your first visit, and that’s just about every time you need to see that specialist.

  • Network part 3 - None of the top facilities accept any ACA plans. Say you get cancer and want to go to the Cleveland Clinic as they are the best at what they do. Flat out can’t go there, they don’t take it. This goes for Cleveland Clinic, Mercy, Baptist, DiMaggio, etc.

  • Dropping coverage - Carriers will drop your coverage out of nowhere with no explanation or notice they are doing so. The individual only finds out when they go to use the policy, and they’d better hope that they’re not trying to use it for anything serious cuz the carrier/marketplace will do absolutely nothing to help you.

  • Step Therapy - Let’s say you take an expensive specialty medication that is the only thing that provides any relief from your health condition. Well, every single time the calendar flips to a new year you have to go through Step Therapy. That means that you have to try a genetic medication and prove it doesn’t work. Then you have to try a brand medication and prove it doesn’t work. Then you can maybe get your specialty drug, but only if it’s on the carrier formulary.

  • Insolvency - Each of the past two years there has been an ACA carrier that has gone belly up. Last year it was Bright Health, this year it’s Friday Health. Imagine picking a plan, going through the hoops of finding a doctor that actually takes it, meeting some or all of your deductible, and then the carrier disappears mid year. You’ve just all of the money you’ve contributed and have to start the entire process over again. Yeesh. I didn’t know it was possible for any insurance company to go out of business, but 2 years in a row it’s happened.

  • Unnecessary Coverage - Does a 60yo woman really need maternity? Does someone that’s never been to nor ever intends to go to a psych need mental health coverage? Does someone that has never taken a drug or drank alcohol in their life need substance abuse coverage? Those are rhetorical questions, but the answer is an overwhelming no. Yet they have to pay to have that as part of their plans even if they’ll never use it.

There’s a lot more that I could list but these are the major ones that come to mind right off the bat.

Look, our health insurance system is fucking terrible across the board, whether it’s ACA or anything else or there… Healthy people that want a nationwide PPO with lower premiums and access to the best facilities in the country should be able to purchase those plans. Removing choice is not the way to fix our system.

I’ll tell you right now, the people that are on short term plans generally love them, and the people on ACA plans generally hate them. This is just going to push people to even shittier fixed inventory or cost share plans which are the worst things out there.

The real reason this is happening is that only the sick and low income individuals are on ACA plans. There’s not enough healthy people to subsidize the cost of treatment for others. Let’s make the ACA better instead of making our options worse.

So what is the solution? Scrap ACA entirely, modify it, improve it, something else? I feel like a public option that is reasonably priced to compete with private insurers and providers is a more actionable option. Disclaimer though, I fully admit I don’t understand healthcare or insurance AT ALL and I only skimmed your post, sorry.

Scrap it entirely and do what the rest of the civilized world does and provide universal healthcare with the ability to supplement with private insurance. That’ll put me basically out of a job, but that’s what needs to be done.

My true solution would be the government offering everyone a social safety net for catastrophic events, something like a $20,000 cap on medical bills lifetime, and then pay cash for everything else. That way doctors and hospitals will actually have to compete for our business, true free market, where the quality of service will increase while out of pocket costs decrease. The only area of healthcare where this has happened is with elective services (lasik, tits & ass, lipo, etc) because the doctors are competing for your business. For people with health conditions have them apply for Medicaid.

That way doctors and hospitals will actually have to compete for our business, true free market, where the quality of service will increase while out of pocket costs decrease.

European chiming in here, which explains my totally communist/socialist viewpoint, I call bullshit. There is no healthcare ‘market’. When a person falls ill, they have no time/energy to seek out the highest quality/most cost-effective hospital or healthcare professionals. They turn to the one that is closest by and specialised in their ailment.

Just like there are no markets for housing, energy, water, public transport and all the other public services that just require deep public investments. These services do not need to make a profit, precisely because profit seeking takes away the investment capacity. This seems to be so hard to understand for folks in the US, I guess the decades long propaganda has taken its toll.

And yes, if one needs a lipo or a breast implant… For sure, that’s a market. As these are completely unnecessary, demand based services.

When a person falls ill, they have no time/energy to seek out the highest quality/most cost-effective hospital or healthcare professionals. They turn to the one that is closest by and specialised in their ailment.

I’m not referring to issues that require immediate attention. Of course if you need to get something taken care of right away you can utilize the public health insurance to get that taken care of. On top of that, with the type of system I suggest, there wouldn’t be a need to “price shop” as the market would drive prices down and determine a standardized cost of service. If you get sick and go to a doctor and get charged some price that is above market standard, you’re sure to remember that and go to a different facility the next time around.

These services do not need to make a profit, precisely because profit seeking takes away the investment capacity.

I am of the firm opinion that health insurance carriers should be not-for-profit companies, I definitely agree with you on this.