A few days ago I was contemplating the difference in experience between photography and video when consuming social media. That was part of a deeper issue though, about how I as a photographer feel about my chosen craft and my own contribution to the art form.

What does it mean to be a photographer these days and does it matter if your work is never finding its way into a physically printed form?

#LongRead #Photography #TheBlog

https://ewenbell.com/blog/What_Is_A_Photographer

Would really like to hear from other photographers on how "digital consumption" has changed how they feel about their craft.

#LongRead #Photography #TheBlog

@ewen An excellent well written article.
Here's a thought, take away profit from the art, then take away the ubiquity of the digital landscape. Do we still create?

Over 10,000 years ago there was a woman who would mark the walls of a cave she shared. A hunt would leave and not return for a couple of days. During this time she daubed the walls with handprints and crude depictions of the life around her. The hunt would return, with much rejoicing, but nobody questioned the marks on the wall.

@justinfarrimond

I started on this path well before I had income. Money is not a driver for being creative, but is a driver for being "productive" :)

I too would sit in the cave and paint, if the rest of the clan were to bring me food!

@ewen I wonder about this too and in the long term. I'm an archivist, and while we do have techniques to preserve digital records, it's not as straightforward as preserving a physical photograph. And the experience of seeing the past on a screen is somehow less fulfilling than actually holding it in your hand. Having said that, I've printed maybe a dozen of the terabytes of photos I've made over the years.

@matthew_fells

The *potential* for preserving digital images seems much greater to me than the physical. They can be backed up for example, and are rarely susceptible to mold outbreaks in my garage!

But that assumes we are actively preserving digital content. Which means moving from one storage medium to another over time. Hard drives fail. etc. Which is a big assumption.

But I digress. The article today is more about the emotional element of print, and how we see ourselves as photographers.

@ewen An enjoyable read, Ewen, expressing many thoughts I agree with, like the need for depth and meaning in photography. That's why I prefer to work in terms of projects, rather than individual images - it gives me meaning and structure to my photography. I often have two or three projects running concurrently and my aim is usually to produce a zine or small, local exhibition. That said, I feel zines have run their course for me personally so I'm at a crossroads facing some uncertainty

@stevenlawson

Great point, the sum is greater than the parts :)

During the pandemic I developed an online workshop for camera clubs to help them build "eBooks" as a way of curating and thinking in terms of collections instead of individual images. Very rewarding, and very well received by participants.

Do you think zine fatigue is a wider issue, or more of a personal exhaustion with the format?

@ewen A bit of both, my last couple of zines didn't sell well at all. I assumed people had just had enough, plus money is very tight these days and zines seem like a luxury. It's not deterring me from producing work, I'm just not sure what I'll do with it. I have just started a year-long project photographing a local country park, which I'm hopeful will at least lead to a council-backed exhibition and book, but for my more personal, artistic/abstract ideas I have no real outlet in mind.

@stevenlawson

Thinking about how hard it is for seasoned campaigners like ourselves, and then imagining what it must feel like for less experienced photographers looking for a path forward.

@ewen Indeed. The photography 'market' is absolutely saturated now, with everyone with an iPhone flooding social media sites with images. It's hard sometimes but I try to remind myself to shoot for my own pleasure, interest and satisfaction first and foremost; if someone else likes my stuff enough to buy a zine or print, that's a lovely bonus.
If no one has told you before let me be the first. You write well. Sure, anybody can write but chunking it beautifully in parts - intro, citing examples, getting to the point, and concluding it - takes practice.

@Deus

Awwwwwww thanks! The first time I got a story published in a magazine I sent a copy to my high school English teacher, because she worked hard for my passing grade I can tell you :)

@ewen thanks for sharing your thoughts Ewen! As a hobbyist shooting with a DSLR I have definitely noticed the effect of social media on photos, to have one clear and obvious subject near the middle and a simple background. Fine details and nuanced compositions don't work on Instagram or phone screens in general. I have never printed, I share my photos digitally with family and friends, and a few to Pixelfed. That said I'm going to show some prints at a cafe soon so that will be interesting!
@ewen I guess if there's a purpose to my photography, it's first of all for my own enjoyment as an activity, and secondly to encourage viewers to pause and consider a subject more deeply. I agree that photography has a somewhat contemplative value compared to other media, especially in the age of video!

@ewen But photography can find a physical form: ‘zines, books, mail art… I’ve done probably 20-30 books or ‘zines, some in unlimited runs and some as single-editions.

People even buy them, which is weird.

@colorblindcowboy

It can find physical forms yes. But my work has almost ceased to exist outside of electrons. Hence the need to write an article about how that makes me feel.