WIth Reddit self-destructing, many have been wondering about alternatives on the Fediverse.

I do NOT recommend Lemmy. I have serious long-standing deep concerns about the developers, see here: https://mstdn.social/@feditips/106835057054633379

As far as I know, nothing has changed since then and Lemmy's issues remain.

Alternatively there's Kbin (https://kbin.social & https://kbin.pub) which seems less problematic. Regarding cryptocurrency issue: https://codeberg.org/fediverse/fediparty/pulls/97#issuecomment-663170

#Reddit #Kbin #Lemmy #Fediverse

FediTips has moved! (@[email protected])

Content warning: Please don't use Lemmy :( Human rights, oppression

Mastodon 🐘

@feditips

I think a site like Reddit can't easily be federated. It bills itself as the "front page of the internet" because it's an aggregator for people to find interesting topics. If you distribute this, there will be many "front pages", which makes the whole "aggregator" concept nonsensical.

And having one Reddit clone as the new "front page" where people use federation only to comment on that site seems to defy federation, too.

Reddit will be succeeded by another centralized service.

@Kathrin @feditips I think Reddit model can actually be better federated than Mastodon... The reason Mastodon sucks (i.e. everyone I know talks about how they're talking in the void on Mastodon) is because Twitter's algorithmic tools are part of the reason for its success. If someone was to make a distributed Reddit where voting up posts mattered, and you could surface upvoted posts to readers, it could catch up a fair bit. Who cares if one instance is more likely to be the Star Wars instance, and that there are 6 Star Trek instances? If I'm on an Expanse-focused instance and I can federate posts from SW and ST instances (maybe the upvotes from my instance count more than their total number of votes from all instances?) I can access that viral experience that Masto declined to embraced by not doing QTs or algos.

@frandroid @Kathrin @feditips

Who's talking into the void?

Mastodon is lovely and friendly and I've been here a hot five minutes and have no claim to fame whatsoever.

@Homebrewandhacking @frandroid @feditips

I agree. I think that's one definitive advantage of a federated system: The local timeline.

It's much easier to stand out among a few hundred active users on a given server than among millions on a centralized system.

@Kathrin

Not being algorithmically suppressed for not being a big account helps too. :)

Hanging out with people in the same time zone definitely helps the sense of immediacy and conversation.

@frandroid @feditips