Recently in fun #genealogy mysteries, I'm researching my wife's GGM Rose, b. 1901 in a small US town. She had a brother Frank, b. ~1894 in Italy. He's with them on the 1900 and 1910 censuses, but then he disappears. He's included in obits for his mother (d. 1944) and brother (d. 1947). We haven't found his birth record yet.

The mystery? We recently got their mom's will (1933). She names all her children, some to mention they already got theirs so they get $1. She doesn't mention Frank AT ALL.

We ordered the will hoping it might clear up other mysteries around the parents. We haven't found any immigration records for them or even a marriage record. We haven't found birth records for Frank or his dad. We think we know what Italian town dad is from, and he has siblings born there, but no record for him. No marriage banns in mom's town. Just nothing. Oh, and when dad died in 1927 here in the US, his obit also named Frank.

So yeah, safe to say mom's will did NOT resolve any mysteries.

@epilanthanomai

Did you look through the Antenati records? Sometimes the birth name is a little different - or 2 names are given but then the person goes by the 2nd name OR the child was born in a nearby town. I've done a lot of research using these records and may be able to help or give you tips.

@girasoli I've searched, but I'm certainly happy to have another pair of eyes, thanks!

The short version is that Luigi Gigliotti was probably born around 1854-59 in or around Caraffa di Catanzaro. His birth year varies from doc to doc, and the location is pieced together from family members.

Antenati has births for Caraffa di Catanzaro from 1809-1865. 1866-1910 are on familysearch.

@girasoli There's an Antonio Gigliotti and Angela Pucci having kids there around that time, and there's a fair bit of circumstantial evidence linking him to them. Happy to go into that if it helps. He _might_ be Lucciano (Caraffa 1860 atto #30), but the year is a bit late, and the name feels like a big stretch without clear evidence to back it up.

@girasoli There's a Luigi Gigliotti born in Caraffa in 1875 (atto #1) who seems way too young. The atto says his mother is the widow of another Luigi, so I guess it's conceivable that there's funny business going on there with dad.

I haven't found a lot of the neighboring comuni on either antenati or familysearch. Awkwardly if he's descended from Antonio Gigliotti and Angela Pucci then their other kids' atti di nascita name them as Don and Donna, so they might have just had money to travel.

@girasoli Or our Luigi could just be unrelated to them and made up hard-to-verify stories to impress his kids ;-)

@epilanthanomai

*1st, is Caraffa di Catanzaro in the Calabria region?
*I'm a little confused. Was the name you were looking for Frank but the records you did find were for a Luigi?
*Do you know the parents of this Frank/Luigi or is that part of the mystery?
Sorry... just trying to figure out from the info you posted.

@epilanthanomai

Gah... posted 2 more replies but they just went to me! Trying again:
I don't have access to the family search records - they are locked for me :<
BUT I'm happy to search the Antenati records .