With the rumblings about Calckey going on it’s really important we all remember to step back from the Tech Tribe nonsense.

It’s not Calckey or Mastodon. It’s “and”. It’s also Pleroma, peertube, Pixelfed, and everything else. Mr Trottier makes a great case for it here.

I’m also likely to have a presence in more than on fedi space, always called “wiredfire” and always (for now) with a Game Boy Camera style avatar
😜

RE:
https://calckey.social/notes/9ejgfcaqom
Chris Trottier (@atomicpoet)

So now the next question: why #Calckey? Calckey is not the only kind of Fediverse server software I operate, and it won't be the last. Currently, I also run a Pleroma server (atomicpoet.org) and a Pixelfed server (peerverse.space). And when #SpaceHost gets off the ground, I plan on running Lemmy, Friendica, Castopod, and Mastodon servers. However, I know exactly where the wind is blowing, and that's with *key apps. #Misskey is already taking Japan by storm. And #Calckey is gaining popularity here in the West. I've also heard that a few more *key apps are in development: one for organizations, the other one specialized for the African-American community. Here's what I've realized. For the Fediverse to truly take off, there needs to be more than just Mastodon. There needs to be something else that shows what *else* is possible on the Fediverse, and it looks like that realization of possibilities will be from the *key apps. If you asked me a year ago what I thought would take off next from the Fediverse, I would have said it will be Pixelfed or PeerTube. That might still be possible, but based on trends since February, it's more likely to be the *key apps. This is ultimately a good thing. For one thing, the popularity of *key apps will finally mean that Mastodon will not longer be synonymous with the Fediverse to the general public. But this also benefits Mastodon because this means that one of the best features of Mastodon will finally be demonstrated: interoperability with other apps. Once people see Mastodon talking with *key -- and vice versa -- they will finally appreciate the true promise of the Fediverse.

Calckey Social
@wiredfire This is nice, but for the general public it creates the same barrier to entry as Desktop Linux. Which distribution/platform/server/app do I choose, what are the differences? Choice overload is a thing. Plus only when one gets traction, like Mastodon has, it gets media coverage and reaches the general public. Plurality is nice but can be scary for the general public. To an Italian wanting to try the fediverse I would say: join mastodon.uno and use Tusky. I wouldn't even mention *key for now.
@Spesknight @wiredfire Which would be an okay option if everyone liked Mastodon -- which they don't. Some people find the feature set to be too limiting, and the UI befuddling.

Should those people leave the Fediverse or should they use a platform more to their taste?

Then there's the matter of *key apps now being the 2nd most popular platform and growing faster proportionally than any other Fediverse platform. They went from less than 25,000 account in January to 320,000 accounts now.

Clearly, there's demand.
@atomicpoet @Spesknight I suspect it’s partly folk coming to the decentralised party via the popularity of mastodon, then looking for something a bit different, that still works. Great to have options that work with each other.

I don’t think *key platforms are likely to eclipse mastodon in the wider public for now, which is absolutely fine and means the concerns of onboarding confusion for now are limited. But it does keep the conversation going which is fantastic. The more we are able to talk to those less familiar with it about the advantages of decentralisation, and in particular fedi, the better.
@wiredfire @Spesknight What I expect to happen is that in the realm of microblogging, Mastodon will be Coke while *key will be Pepsi.

Everyone who wants to self-host or have a small community will continue to user Pleroma/Akkoma.

And gradually, there will be more custom Fediverse apps for specific use cases.
@[email protected] @[email protected] Feels like the early web again, but better 😁