#DaveGoulson gave a speech about #insects at #TheBigOne #climate demo on Saturday 22nd April. This is the text:

”I’ve got 5 minutes to talk to you about *insects*. I love insects, always have. Let me tell you a bit about them. Insects have been around for 480 million years, that means they are twice as old as the oldest dinosaurs. They’ve survived the previous 5 mass extinction events.

1/8

Over the millennia they’ve evolved into a bewildering variety of forms, colours, shapes, beautiful, weird and wonderful. There are over a million known species, and we suspect there may be another 3 or 4 million awaiting discovery.

#insects #ClimateEmergency #DaveGoulson

2/8

Insects are *hugely* important—they are food for many larger creatures such as birds and bats, they help to control crop pests, they recylce dung, dead bodies, leaves and so on, help to keep the soil healthy, and of course they pollinate wildflowers and 75% of our crops. The world would grind to a halt without insects. Love them or loathe them, we need insects.

#insects #ClimateEmergency #DaveGoulson

3/8

Sadly, insect populations are in rapid *decline*. In Germany, the biomass of flying insets fell by 76% over just 27 years. Here in the UK, insect abundance has fallen by 60% in 20 years. The ranges of butterflies have shurnk by over 40% since 1976.

#insects #ClimateEmergency #DaveGoulson

4/8

More broadly, we are in the sixth *mass extinction* event, with species going extinct faster than they have for 65 million years, since a meteor wiped out the dinosaurs. Every day, every hour, species go extinct. Drip by drip, the lifeblood of our planet is draining away.

So what is our *government* doing about it? Nothing useful.

#insects #ClimateEmergency #DaveGoulson

5/8

Our *civilization*, our children’s health and wellbeing, and the future of much of the life that remains on our planet, hangs in the balance. For at least thirty years it has been painfully obvious that we are heading for disaster, yet our response has been woefully inadequate. Successive governments have abjectly failed to grasp the importance of the threat we face.

#insects #ClimateEmergency #DaveGoulson

6/8

They just don’t get it. Therese Coffey recently gave permission for UK sugar beet farmers to use *neonicotinoid pesticides*—these are banned across Europe because they are so toxic to bees and other insects. her own scientific advisory committee—the ECP—repeatedly advised against this. So much for following the science. Meanwhile, we’re opening a new coal mine, prospecting for more oil and gas, dumping raw sewage into our rivers 800 times per day… I could go on. They just don’t get it.

7/8

It makes me sad, frustrated, *angry*. We live on a beautiful planet. It is unique. It gives us everything. There really is no planet B. Surely we have a duty of care for all the creatures that live on it, big and small. Looking after our planet must be our top priority. It should be our politican’s top priority. Without insects, without nature, there will be no economic growth, there will be no economy. Without nature, nothing else will matter.”

~ #DaveGoulson

#insects #ClimateEmergency

8/8

bodhidave (@[email protected])

Attached: 1 image @[email protected] Saw this quotation yesterday from Prof. Robin Wall Kimmerer's book, *Braiding Sweetgrass.* Prof. Kimmerer is a botanist and member of the Potawatomi Nation. ❤️ 🙏

Mastodon 🐘
@bodhidave
I am going to pick up this book on Friday from the library! 💚
@natureworks I am certain they get it. This is deliberate eyes-wide-open destruction of nature & society (as the UK countryside is key to British culture). The dead hand of the ERG at work for the 0.2%.
@unearth
Oh yeah, they get it, they simply don't care. Saw a great slogan in London, "Keep Warm, Take Power, Join The Rebellion"

@unearth @natureworks

OPEC+ and #KochNetwork has spent over $127 million on climate denialism.

Republican billionaire donors spent nearly a billion buying the 2022 midterms in the USA. Much of it from the oil industry & its financiers.

The public corruption in the Republican, Tory, and Conservative parties is clearly visible.

These oil interests are prepared to start wars and end democracy itself to keep frying the planet.

https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/fighting-climate-chaos/climate-deniers/front-groups/

Koch-funded Climate Denial Front Groups

From 1997 to 2017, the Kochs funneled $127,006,756 to 92 organizations that advance the Kochs' attacks on climate change science while presenting themselves as experts. These organizations are listed below:

Greenpeace USA
@natureworks

The devil is in the detail. You say you "just don't get it" and that's because the sources you used have presented you with half-truths and manipulated facts to create an impression of the decision being utterly absurd and outrageously anti-scientific.

In reality, it's not.

> DEFRA: "We evaluate the risks very carefully and only grant temporary emergency authorisations for restricted pesticides in special circumstances when strict requirements are met and there are no alternatives."

So they don't "give permission to use" on daily basis whenever they like, but granted an one-time exception based on specific emergency.

> Twelve EU countries including France, Belgium, Denmark and Spain have given emergency authorisations for neonicotinoid use in the last three years.

So it's not exclusive UK post-Brexit arrogance but a widely accepted emergency measure applied in exceptional cases and in general it's still just as banned in the UK as in EU.

> Flowering crops which would attract pollinators could not be grown in fields treated with the pesticide for 32 months after application.

So those who use neonicotinides to respond to that one time emergency actually do seem to care about insects (even if it's in their own business interest) and take measures to reduce harm.

> For this reason, it was not possible to rule out completely a degree of risk to bees (and this is the case even with a 32-month exclusion) from flowering plants in or near the field in the years after neonicotinoid use.

So it's not like ECP stated that even one time use will result in killing all bees in UK, but simply stated it's not possible to "rule out completely a degree of risk", which is a drastically different level of risk assessment. As someone who works in risk assessment professionally, I can give the following example: you "can't rule out completely" a risk of a meteorite falling on your house tomorrow, the risk is out there and you accept it on daily basis.

Just to clarify: I'm all for a general ban on use of neonicotinides but I'm also against activism based on hype, manipulation and half-truths whose only purpose is to build a tribal, black-and-white perception of the world divided between endlessly good activists and endlessly evil farmers. If you look at the real picture you actually see a real environmentalism in action, where farming industry is doing something under strict control of regulations and in accordance to the best harm reduction practices when they have no other choice.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/202...
UK overrules scientific advice by lifting ban on bee-harming pesticide

Campaigners aghast as emergency exemption on use of thiamethoxam granted due to risk to sugar beet crop

The Guardian

@kravietz this is a thread from Professor Dave Goulson's speech, not myself, and I would imagine he is eminently qualified to make such a statement.

Evidence based is great, and the evidence is that neonictinoids should not be used as a pesticide.

Evidence is also that we're in the midst of a sixth extinction, and industrial agriculture is playing a huge part in this.

@natureworks It's a good 5 minute speech.

But.

The problem isn't that "they" don't "get it". People who merely don't understand are educable and persuadable. The problem is that the powers that be do understand and don't care. Either we change the power or this current mass extinction will include most, if not all, humans.

@haq I really could not agree more! This is a *political* problem. Capitalism is killing the planet.