I know I'm a broken record on this, but I so wish Mastodon had a simple mechanism similar to quote-retweeting.

For me a lot of the fun of Twitter is using someone else's thought as a jumping point for starting a conversation with mutuals/followers.

Direct-replying is great if you want to join a conversation in someone else's community, but that's not always what I want to do.

I remember Twitter when quote retweets were manual, and I felt like I had to really force myself to scan headlines for something to talk about and then bring that to Twitter if I wanted a presence there.

I did it, bc I wanted to use Twitter for my organizing, but it was so unfun.

What really got me to the point of *enjoying* Twitter was the back-and-forth that quote-retweets allowed.

It lets you very easily reply in a way that ropes your own community into the conversation without cutting off the OP or appearing to plagiarize them.

So now I have "post to mastodon" on my weekday daily to do list, but it still feels like a chore.

Part of it is that I haven't built a ton of community here yet.

But part of it is also that I think the lack of this functionality makes that community-building process less intuitive and more difficult.

@gwensnyder oh me toooooo… it’s a bit of a slog but I really want it to become good. I am not sure it will.

@emmalbriant @gwensnyder
The alternative that I've heard is to reply to the toot, and then boost your reply. If I understand it correctly (I'm new here and might NOT understand), your followers then see your reply and the toot you're replying to.

What would quote-tooting add?

@BlueDot @emmalbriant @gwensnyder
You can also copy the link to the post and paste in fresh toot adding your own commentary, if you really want to do the “sideband comment” thing —which BTW is exactly the same thing that Twitter does behind the scenes in a QT. Yes, there isn't a button to do this specifically: such a marginal amount of friction helps prevent low-effort abuse without really hindering legitimate uses.
@oblomov @BlueDot @gwensnyder look I know you can paste a link. That is not the same as quite tweeting/tooting.

@emmalbriant @BlueDot @gwensnyder

Would you be satisfied with the link copy-paste mechanism if the card/preview was turned into a nested view of the linked toot instead of the current hundreds-character preview?

@oblomov @BlueDot @gwensnyder yes that would be better