When I want to understand how a virus originated, I always turn to "low confidence" assessments from some random bureaucrats in an agency that has no expertise in virology, genetics, or epidemiology.

Thank you, random Department of Energy people, for leaking your baseless speculation to the Wall Street Journal.

@maxkennerly
The JGI guys are on this platform somewhere. They work for DoE and they know virology.
I think they're probably not allowed to be raising their voices right now...

I'm also sure none of them were involved in this statement.

But hey, I wish the Fox News people well with their attempts to retrieve damages. I think we could benefit from redomiciling many overly outsourced industries.

@dnavinci @maxkennerly

I did a search for 'virology' on the JGI portal, and came up with bupkis. Your mastodon instance screams that you know something I don't, though.

The question still remains, what's the DOE doing, pontificating on covid?

@skydog
Yeah, spycraft and foreign policy arent really a bailiwyck of that department, so I'm just as shocked as anyone. Mostly I'm surprised that Granholm would allow a statement like that that turns her department into more of a lightning rod than it already was. Almost every election cycle there a major conservative voice threatening to remove the whole dept.

1/2

@maxkennerly

@dnavinci @skydog @maxkennerly

Much of the anti-vaxxer disinformation & covid malign influence campaigns were funded by the oil industry.

It's an industry that's openly hostile to democracy. They believe that prolonging the pandemic will destabilize democracies & increase profit.

They've funded trucker blockades in Canada that cost their economy billions. They're funding the yellow vest movement in France. They're funding the Tufton Street think tanks kneecapping the UK.

They own the GOP.

@Npars01
Didn't people use a lot less oil during the pandemic peak?
Maybe some long game I don't understand?
Usually those folks can't see past their quarterly bonus...
@skydog @maxkennerly

@dnavinci @skydog @maxkennerly

People may have used less oil during the pandemic but profits increased.

Price gouging is politically useful.

Republicans & Tories spent the pandemic blaming liberals for high gas prices then promptly dropped this talking point after the elections.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/294614/revenue-of-the-gas-and-oil-industry-in-the-us/

https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/220927/dq220927d-eng.htm

Gas and oil industry revenue U.S. 2022 | Statista

In 2022, the total revenue of the United States’ oil and gas industry came to 332.9 billion U.S.

Statista
@Npars01
Always get a bit nervous when people point at US oil profits as evidence of conspiracy. It's not that the oil companies don't engage is deep nefarious plots (they definitely do), but the profits are almost always acquired by fixed percentage markup.
@skydog @maxkennerly

@dnavinci @skydog @maxkennerly

There's some evidence of oil price manipulation over Putin's war on Ukraine.

https://mobile.twitter.com/70sbachchan/status/1498158636849405955

Mysterious surcharges suddenly appeared on the LNG market.

https://www.gov.ca.gov/2023/02/22/top-5-takeaways-from-todays-hearing-on-big-oils-price-gouging/

High fuel prices triggered blackouts in Asia & kneecapped their economies

https://www.politico.com/news/2023/02/25/why-russias-war-is-causing-blackouts-in-asia-00084435

Oil price volatility deliberately maximized profits & political pain for democracies accelerating their transition to renewables.

https://www.gov.ca.gov/2022/12/06/top-10-reasons-for-a-price-gouging-penalty-on-big-oil/

https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news-release/2023/01/more-rampant-gas-price-gouging-exxon-reaps-obscene-56-billion

Albert Pinto on Twitter

“1/ A hot war, a financial war, & nuclear M.A.D... A question to zoom out: Did high energy prices embolden Putin? Are the commodities markets responsible for Russia’s invasion of Ukraine? @rupert_russell’s timely new book 'Price Wars' says: YES. https://t.co/jefimrliXc”

Twitter
@Npars01
Yeah, I don't think anyone missed Russian LNG prices and supply as being central to this particular conflict.
I don't think that's something that anyone should need to be convinced about. Like... What did anyone think was going to happen after Nordstream was bombed?
@skydog @maxkennerly

@dnavinci @skydog @maxkennerly

High oil prices are both a boon and a bane.

High prices incentivize more oil drilling and governments are pressured to give in to industry demands for yet more subsidies.

The oil industry uses windfall profits to interfere in elections & mess with government functions like pollution regulations, voting rights, civil rights rollbacks, gun safety, & attacks on Social Security & Medicare.

High gas prices at the pump incentivize the transition to renewables.

@Npars01
Alright. I think this is a bit off the rails.
But yeah, I'd like to see prices stay high. That's how we get the activation energy for a transition.
@skydog @maxkennerly