Two years ago, we bought Wirecutter’s recommended citrus juicer. It’s widely the highest-rated one on Amazon.

It’s garbage. Utter crap.

Today, I’ve replaced it with the same model I grew up with: a West-German 1965 Braun MPZ1.

My mom got hers in the 90s from my grandma when they moved and it continues to work to this day. I got this one from eBay for $30. Unbelievable torque, excellent plastics, a single lemon tray insert (awesome), and a power cord I ought to replace 😂

@snazzyq I’ve found both Wirecutter’s and Amazon’s top picks (often the same products) aren’t reliably the best, or even very good — what it often means is that they’re the cheapest ones that work acceptably, which leaves very little useful guidance when you actually want a really good one.
@marcoarment Very often true. There ought to be a Wirecutter alternative for kinda-fancy things when it’s something you care about. Like John’s kitchen gadgets 😂
@snazzyq @marcoarment like if there was a site that was… hyper critical or something…