For my latest newsletter, I wrote a thing about JK Rowling and "separating the art from the artist." I have thoughts!

https://buttondown.email/charliejane/archive/jk-rowling-and-separating-the-art-from-the-artist/

J.K. Rowling and "Separating the Art from the Artist"

In case you've been living under some kind of magical rock, there's a new Harry Potter tie-in video game out now, called Hogwarts Legacy. I honestly wasn't...

@charliejane yes, yes, all of that. I am not a celebrity, I'm just a shmuck who sits alone in a room and writes.

Wearing my "English Degree" hat, I also feel obliged to throw out: "separating art from the artist" is a postmodern critical tool, intended for literary analysis. Using it routinely is like saying, "I hear hydraulic jackhammers are way cool, I need one for my apartment."

For most of history, art and artist were one and the same.

For people not engaging in literary analysis, SAFA is misuse of a professional tool. Which, fine, play with literary tools all you want, talking about art is cool, but don't claim that this tool is the unimpeachable cultural standard! It just isn't.

@mwl @charliejane OH, but THIS literary tool can be used to separate ethics from consumption, which is what people REALLY want. They want to have what they want without having to be responsible for its effects.