Republican Sen. Josh Hawley is calling for a TikTok ban.

This is a day after another Republican, Sen. Marco Rubio, published an OpEd in Fox News also pushing for a ban.

To be sure, these Republicans care very little about TikTok's surveillance of users.

Their problem is that, unlike Meta or Twitter, TikTok is not an American company.

Nevertheless, I personally think surveillance capitalism should be banned wholesale on all social networks.

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/international-business/us-business/article-us-senator-josh-hawley-wants-to-ban-tiktok-nationwide/

U.S. Senator Josh Hawley wants to ban TikTok nationwide

‘TikTok is China’s backdoor into Americans’ lives. It threatens our children’s privacy as well as their mental health,’ U.S. Senator Josh Hawley said on Twitter

The Globe and Mail

I really hope that progressives turn off the lizard brain response of "TikTok is good because Republicans say it's bad."

No, TikTok is bad.

The enemy of your enemy isn't necessarily your friend.

Is their opposition based on nationalism, racism, and yellow peril? Probably.

Is TikTok still monitoring and tracking teenagers, feeding them unhealthy content based on "relevancy" algorithms, screwing with their mental health? Yes.

All surveillance capitalism should be banned.

@atomicpoet I think the part that strikes me as being tremendously tricky in regards to TikTok is the fact that on the one hand, yes... TikTok is a surveillance app.

But on the other, whether we like it or not, TikTok is also viewed as a creative outlet and a source of community for many of the users who are posting videos there. It's easy to dismiss it all as banality and commercialism, because indeed most that floats to the top of it is.... There are plenty of thriving communities of people who aren't chasing trends, just talking about their lives same as we are on the Fediverse, they're just using video and TikTok was the most easeful platform to do so on. Hell, one of my oldest Internet friends met her wife on TikTok through finding a thriving community of over 40 lesbians on there.

My fear is that what will get lost in the shuffle is the fact that while we're busy crusading surveillance capitalism, we're also alienating groups of people who are going to perceive these efforts as curtailing their right to freedom of speech, especially if alternatives are not available.

And given that the Republicans are leading the charge on that effort at the moment.... it's VERY likely it will be perceived among the populous that way.

@nikkiana The problem isn't their speech. It's how TikTok functions.

The blame should be out straight at the feet of TikTok.

They can pivot to another business model, but they won't.