my house is full of cat toys and the only ones he'll touch are ponytail holders and the crinkly plastic rings that seal the tops of plastic bottles
@ian Our kitty Ripley likes ponytail holders and these teensy lightweight balls, possibly for the same reason: she can carry them in her mouth and drop them on our faces while we attempt to sleep. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01C2NLVBY/
Amazon.com