By the way, Southwest blew $5.6 billion on stock buybacks in the past few years.

They could have made investments in their services and infrastructure.

They could have prepared for extreme weather events.

But no. They decided to enrich their shareholders.

@rbreich
Stock buybacks should be illegal.

Stock buybacks after a bailout should be mandatory jail time.

@TCatInReality @rbreich curious about this stance. I get the concern about using funds from a bailout to do stock buybacks. But if that isn’t the case why are stock buybacks bad outright?
Serious question since I wasn’t aware of an inherent problem with them but might have a blind spot.

@mitchdenny @rbreich
What's inherently wrong w buybacks?
- market manipulation
- redirects money that could go into business investments/expansion
- indicative of price gouging
- shifted exec comp to stock performance vs business performance

Buybacks were illegal until Reagan. We forget that.

@mitchdenny @rbreich
Prior to Reagan, companies typically balanced 3 priorities: growth, customers and employees. Exec comp reflected that. Look at annual reports from the 50s and 60s.

Then that shifted solely to shareholders. That's led to mass layoffs, wage stagnation, price gouging, underinvestment, consolidations - and exec comp skyrocketed because they were paid on stock price. A company could be declining, but could still grow the stock price w buybacks.

#BanStockBuybacks

@TCatInReality @mitchdenny @rbreich

Then along came a Nobel Prize winning economist from U Chicago who sagely pointed out - it's the shareholder stupid. And so it now is.

@GWD @TCatInReality @rbreich I guess I'm not versed enough in the pros/cons of buy backs either from a business point of view nor an ethical perspective, which is what was behind my question. Based on this conversation I can now see that there are at least some causes for concern that are at least worth discussing.
@mitchdenny @TCatInReality @rbreich It's hard to talk about share buybacks in sound bites, and it's really a second order issue. Deeper issue is putting shareholders above everything else all the time. Read Milton Friedman's piece in Sunday Times Mag from 1970 ish. He lays out the basic arguments there. Ideas took hold! Then executive comp. got wound in. The whole edifice needs a make over.