May 2021, December 2022

Emma Green must be cursed to keep writing the same exact story where she sneers at people who wear masks

Hundreds of thousands of people in the U.S. have died from COVID between the publication of those two pieces, but she seems as unfazed as ever and convinced that people who took COVID seriously were somehow overreacting.

It's just such a frustrating type of journalism, with the writer's pre-formed opinion driving the direction.

And, I think it's worth keeping in mind, that these types of articles (there was another just the other day in NYT about "the last holdouts" i.e. people who still wear masks) are taking issue with people *choosing* to wear masks places. For the most part, mask mandates (which were always pretty limited) just aren't happening anywhere anymore. This is all very "your personal behavior irritates me and I don't like to be reminded that COVID happened."

It's bizarre. It's controlling.

Because while there's definitely a collective argument to be made that other people *should* mask (as their lack of precautions increase everyone's risks), there just isn't an argument to be made for why people *shouldn't* wear masks if they choose to.

So since late 2020-ish, there have been these writers who put out pieces where they try to create an argument against masks.

Those pieces inevitably boil down to a few implicit and explicit points:

Aesthetics:

So much of those pieces come down to "I don't like seeing things that remind me of the pandemic" or something similar. The point of these pieces is to create a social stigma around masks so that people who wear them might feel social pressure to ditch it.

@parkermolloy I also think early the pandemic there were a bunch of guys who see a mask and it reminds them of a bra and think it feminizes them. They of course don’t say that — instead they appear to think wearing a mask is an unwarranted fear response. It’s of course sensible and perfectly reasonable to manage COVID risk with masks. Also masks can look super cool and work really well. I have a very high tolerance for risk and am extremely low tolerance for hurting others.