If I had maybe five dollars every time someone suggested "build your own instance" as a solution to any problem encountered on the fediverse, I might not need student loan forgiveness.

That aside, before you're tempted to respond to a critique of the fediverse with "build your own instance," consider that the suggestion is a polite way of saying "go the fuck away?"

I have written some what at length about why "build your own instance" is not an ideal solution for many communities; however, I would like to put all of that aside to make clear a point I thought was too simple to be mentioned.

The entire point of the critique is because we wish to exist in the same space as others as our full selves, and not some sanitized version limited by norms of conduct.

"Build your own instance," in essence, is a refusal to consider the possibility that we'd like to be our whole selves in community with others, rather than having to build our own walled gardens. On this view, it becomes a doubling down on the unacceptability for certain people to be authentically themselves within a digital social space.

To be clear, whether mastodonians intend to reinforce this perspective is immaterial: the suggestion has the practical and affective force of telling those of us who level critiques that the fediverse will not shift its norms to enable a plurality of ways of being.

As a result, we might as well pack it in because our full selves are not welcome in community with others.

I have resisted making plain this meaning because, to me, it seemed too harsh. I wanted to give mastodonians the benefit of the doubt. However, as a great thinker once said "when someone shows you who they are, believe them." And one of the things that "build your own instance" shows me is the degree to which mastodonians are willing to tolerate some people in their social spaces.

Now, I know that many folks On Here will ask for a solution to this issue and I actually have one. Like many solutions in my area of expertise, it is not a technical solution but it may be just as hard.

Ask yourself why "build your own instance" is your first response to someone who points out that they find it to be their full selves in a given space. Ask yourself why your suggestion is for them to leave? As yourself what that accomplishes.

Then get back to me.

@shengokai
From the perspective of a Vietnamese American, born in the US... "Build your own instance" sounds a lot like "Go back to where you came from!" This thinking isn't just confined to virtual spaces like the Fediverse, but is pervasive throughout our society. What we need to fix our way of thinking. That isn't easy, but is worth doing anyway.

Thank you for your insight.

@thekat03 @shengokai Pardon me for intruding but i really disagree with that analogy.Instances r communities built around similar interests, I can genuinely see reasons behind why someone would say find a different instance or build your own instance.If the majority of the community in that instance learn towards something you disagree with, or have interests that you don't believe in, then you most definitely should find a different community where you can feel included
@jovantyk @shengokai
There absolutely are good reasons for some people to choose to create their own instance. Choosing to do so, and being pressured to do so, are very different. When people say, "Go back to where you came from," they never mean Ohio. "Go make your own instance" has the same vibe. Now, a "There's advantages to making your own instance" is more polite, but repeatedly being told that, and given no other chance to become a part of the community, is still just a polite "Go away."
@thekat03 @shengokai I wish people stopped trying to equate mastodon to real life analogies, it's not the same thing. When people say you should build your instance it's not the same as irl people telling you to go back to where you came from. Mastodon is built around the idea of instances for everyone. So when someone suggests to find a different instance, they're doing it because they care about your interests
@jovantyk @shengokai
I understand that people mean well when advising people to go to another instance or make their own instance. How a message is intended is not necessarily the same as how it's received. Please listen to our black peers to better understand this difference.
@thekat03 @shengokai Wha- What does this have anything to do with race?
@jovantyk Please, if you do not understand why many black people have been having much worse experiences when they come to mastodon than white people, listen to what people like @shengokai are saying.