Fediverse server admins: have you considered putting a limit on the number of people that can join your instance?

If not, please do.

(This should really be a feature in fediverse servers like Mastodon, etc. “Max occupancy” or something with an auto-shutoff when it’s reached.)

Remember, small is beautiful ;)

If nothing else, I’m sure none of you want to become mini Zuckerbergs or Musks – eww – so let’s make sure we set the right incentives from the start.

#fediverse #scale #smallness

@aral

Maybe there should be gradually more friction on joining as the limiit is approached?

Otherwise it's like "99,999 - come on in!" ➡️ "100,000 - go somewhere else!" and people who aren't sure how federation works may be confused. The momentum of everyone joining may tempt the admin to stay open.

Maybe when a server gets to (for example) 70% of capacity it could switch to the "why do you want to be a member?" form which creates a bit more friction, and might push people to look elsewhere.

@FediThing @aral When II just joined, my intuition was "oh, I dunno, so I'll join a big one", so obviously some mild incentive to not follow that instinct for servers will be helpful

@gassygrassly @aral

Yeah, even making people aware big servers are a problem would be a start.

At the moment there's no info about this when you sign up.