Framing environmental deterioration as the result of poor individual choices—littering, leaving the lights on when we leave a room, failing to car-pool—not only distracts us from identifying and demanding change from the real drivers of environmental decline. It also removes these issues from the political realm to the personal, implying that the solution is in our personal choices rather than in better policies, business practices, and structural context.

-- Annie Leonard, "Moving from Individual Change to Societal Change"

http://www.pfree.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Moving-from-Individual-Change-to-Societal-Change-Annie-Leonard-2013.pdf

#AnnieLeonard #SocietalChange #IndividualResponsibilityFallacy #RiskShifting #ResponsibilityShifting

@dredmorbius Really frustrates me when individuals/consumers tries to pass the buck, saying things like “oh we can still have cheeseburgers and cigarettes, the problem is Roxxon Oil Corporation.” EVERYONE needs to step the fuck up re this! Corporations, goverments, NGOs, clubs, organizations, families, even individuals! EVERYONE!

Littering, leaving the light on, and car culture are not and will never be cool!

@Sandra This past February I'd had an appointment, TV playing in the reception area, COVID news.
Receptionist looked at it and ccommented that she wished the news wouldn't make such a big deal out of it. Needlessly caring people.

"This is big, and it's going to be far bigger", I said.

The office was closed for the next three months. I've not seen that receptionist there again, on a couple of visits. And tis thing is still going on and will be for a while.

But yeah: climate, energy, resources, pollution: things are going to hange beyond all possible recognition. And not just corps or the rich. (Most reading this are the global rich.)

@dredmorbius @Sandra (adding a thought, not diagreeing) why not both engagement against the big corporations and doing all the (maybe just symbolic) things in personal life? I think they would strengthen each other. It's the implicit theory that there's only limited attention,goodwill, and capacity for change in the population, so we need to choose our battles and take small steps. is that really how it works?

@coldwave Of the two, the systemic approach is far more effective. Create a world in which peope can only do the right thing (or have to work much harder not to), and the problem resolves.

It's also the proper answer to this bullshit (on plastics pollution):

I'm confused how this is anything other than "Coca-Cola the worlds most popular beverage maker" Coca-Cola didn't do anything to put that garbage there, people who consumed their product did.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25381647

Coke created the bottles, the market for their flavured sugar water, the supply and distribution ecosystem, the regulatory and legal frameworks, etc.

I'll do the responsible thing myself (refuse, reduce, reuse, recycle) and haven't had a Coke (or other soft drink) in years, probably a decade or more. But billions of other people do.

I can't change that through individual action. Collectively addressing systemic change can.

@Sandra

I'm confused how this is anything other than "Coca-Cola the worlds most popular ... | Hacker News

@dredmorbius I don’t think that (the quoted excerpt) is 100% bullshit.

Coca-Cola should stop and consumers should also stop. It’s “why are you hitting yourself” all over again. Stop passing the buck. “Of the tw—“ both are needed (or, all three if we bring policy makers into the mix)! Or, only one is needed, idk, but if the one of the three legs that need to stop is us consumers, then get to it —- and if it’s them, stop paying them! Most likely all three legs need to change. Consumers, business, and policy.

I am privileged and grateful to have access to potable tap water. It’s difficult for a lot of people to have access to clean drink. People are doing what they can and some even going above and beyond, to fight the climate disaster.

I’m not about guilt-tripping people. We are facing a difficult time. But it pisses me off to no end when people are actively saying “do nothing, do nothing, it’s not consumers, it’s all b2b and elites”.