Thanks. Yeah, I don’t know what all the hullabaloo about “a different movie” works be then. Maybe a pristine print hits a little different and reveals details that make it feel more like what it is, but I tend to agree this is just people with unrealistic expectations of the movie that basically started modern VFX.
Since you seem to be informed, I have a potential Mandela effect to discuss. I have a distinct recollection of seeing multiple pre-SE versions on TV and/or VHS, but the only difference I remember is that one of them included a few seconds of Threepio explaining the contents of the plans/maps Artoo was downloading in the initial guard room they take over. The dialogue sounded distinctly and sloppily ADR’d. Have you ever heard of anything like that?
Best wishes and fingers crossed. It sounds terrifying.
Unrelated, but hopefully appreciated, this little corner of Lemmy has brought me a lot of joy.
It’s really hard to tell from the article just how different it is. You’ve got Kathy Kennedy saying “I’m not even sure there’s another one quite like it… It’s that rare.” But then you’ve got them talking like it’s exactly what anyone who watched the film from 1977-1980 would have seen.
The headline also oversells how “bad” it was. This from the article (with adequate context) felt more on point:
“I felt like I was watching a completely different film,” wrote Robbie Collin, who called the print a “joyously craggy, grubby, stolidly carpentered spectacle” that “looks more like fancy dress than grand sci-fi epic.” “Every scene had the visceral sense of watching actual people photographed doing actual things with sets and props that had been physically sawn and glued into place. The slapstick between C-3PO and R2-D2 looked clunkier, and therefore funnier; the Death Star panels were less like supercomputers than wooden boards with lights stuck on, and so better attuned to the frequency of make-believe. It felt less like watching a blockbuster in the modern sense than the greatest game of dressing up in the desert anyone ever played.”
To the extent it’s relevant, Mr. Collin is also juuust young enough (born 82 or 83) to have missed all three OT films in their original run. For the record, I saw ROTJ first-run as a little kid and it remains the one for which I am the most irrationally protective. This would be as opposed to The Last Jedi, which is the one for which I am the most defensibly and objectively protective. Pardon me while I retrieve my asbestos suit.
First time for this one. Kind of confusing, but I think I’ll get the hang of it.