Neural Energy: The Science of Soul and Consciousness in Star Trek; and why we cannot replicate, but transport living beings - Star Trek: Website
Hey there, I have always been of the opinion that so-called Treknobabble
actually (with only few exceptions) is internally consistent and makes sense if
you accept some of its premises. It’s not just random words strung together, it
makes sense if you simply listen to the characters and accept that their
scientific understanding differs from ours. Therefore, this is actually a piece
of head-canon that I assume is largely intentional, and it’s about the concept
of a soul, and where consciousness comes from in the Trek universe. So far, I
have not been disappointed with this explanation; and it actually explains some
of the more illogical parts of how consciousness and “a soul” supposedly exist
in Star Trek. Sentient beings in the Star Trek universe have a “soul”; some kind
of energy field that is created by their neural system naturally. We call it a
neural energy field or a bio-neural energy field; and we don’t yet know how to
create or replicate ones ourselves, only how to move them. This is the reason
why we cannot clone-transport or replicate conscious beings: we have a way to
move the neuro-electric field from A to B via the transporter beam, but we
cannot create any new ones; any living being we would replicate would be just
cells, out of a consciousness, practically a zombie. That’s how we can transport
someone from here to there, but not clone them; this is how we can replicate
meat, but not a living animal. This is also how telepathy works: if
consciousness is merely some kind of energy field, we can manipulate it however
we want by simply applying physical methods. Let’s look at a few of the
appearances in canon: - In VOY 1x13 (Cathexis), Chakotay’s “bio-neural energy”
is displaced, practically his consciousness, and can even ‘enter’ other beings.
This implies that his consciousness is separate from his body, and can be moved
around, and even “possess” others: the mind is totally separate from the body. -
In DIS 2x11/2x12, they store someone’s “bio-neural energy”, a representation of
their consciousness, and it is said that it can uniquely identify a person. -
According to DS9 4x10 (Our Man Bashir), during transport, someone’s “neural
energy” pattern is stored within the transporter buffer. The energy pattern
occupies a huge amount of memory and so cannot be stored for a long period of
time. In the same episode, they also establish “neural energy” to be separate
from the physical form. They use the word “store” instead of “save”; I think
that’s because it’s literally something like a battery, not a photocopier. You
can only move around the consciousness. - In VOY 4x13 (Waking Moments), they
encounter a species which seems to be unconscious, but actually has a
consciousness independent of its physical form; that even is able to pull others
in with it. This is, once again, called a “neurogenic field”. This implies that
the consciousness (the neural energy field) of people can be physically
manipulated like any other energy, to induce hallucinations or dreams. - In VOY
6x05 (Alice), there is a “neurogenic interface”, which seems to enable the user
to connect their own neuro-electric field with the computer in order to transfer
data from one source to the other, to connect the consciousness to another body,
so to speak. This mirrors the ability to possess others from Cathexis. - In ENT
4x10 (Daedalus) we find a disembodied transporter signal that contains a human’s
consciousness and that can once again haunt things and people. This could very
well be the person’s neuro-electric field from the pattern buffer, somehow
broken free, in a very similar way to the independent-soul possession mechanics
from Cathexis and Alice. - In TOS and Enterprise, we also see many references to
the Vulcan concept of “katra”; a person’s consciousness, independent from a
body, that can be stored in a device, transferred to others, and communicated
with for example via a mind meld. Sound familiar? - In DS9 1x09 (The Passenger),
Julian Bashir is possessed by a Vulcan’s consciousness, and Dax ends up removing
the consciousness by using an “electromagnetic pulse” to “displace the pattern”.
This once again strengthens the idea of consciousness being nothing but an
electromagnetic field. There are tons more (literally, dozens
[https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Neural_pattern]) examples of people’s
consciousnesses being represented by some kind of electromagnetic field
independent of their bodies; often called “neural pattern”, “neural energy”, or
a variation thereof. It is surprisingly consistent. So, what about Data, and the
Doctor, and all the other artificial life forms? It seems to be simple to say
now that the “measure of a man” is simply whether they are able to create a
neuro-electric field or not. However, if this was the case, the entire
philosophical debate on whether Data is a being or not would not make much
sense: they could simply scan him to find out whether there is, in fact, one, or
not. I therefore assume that he does not have one (there is also no canon
reference to any neuro-anything when it comes to Data), and that positronic
brains “merely” simulate consciousness. I propose a more radical approach: it
does not matter whether an artificial lifeform is actually conscious or only
simulates consciousness perfectly; for all intents and purposes, they should be
treated equal to all other beings.
