I think Motherbaord and other coverage of this site sets up bad expectations of "Twitter without bad people." Social networks have bad people and friction. Dealing with them is an difficult and often inherently unsatisfying process.

Real issue is simply Mastodon's governance.

I was on Twitter in 2007. Early Twitter was completely different. Everything starts off new and full of promise. The glow fades. Its in how networks manage maturation that is important.