whenever someone says "i always knew i was trans" i feel myself curl up and grow a bit of shell.

i never knew i was trans. i barely do now.

i went 40 years without being able to accept this about myself. i have now — and it's fucking great, and i love it — but it still feels so precarious. so slight. like someone could lean down and gently blow, and it would fly away.

cis folks don't matter. they can do whatever, i don't care, they can't take this from me.

but it hurts and scares me — still — when trans people say "i always knew". it seems like such a universally shared trans experience, that it almost feels like a requirement. one that i'm failing.

"i always knew" — such confidence! such security. perhaps it's this confidence and security that leads these trans folks to be the ones who tell their stories, and that's why all the stories i read are by people who feel this way.

maybe there are post-realization trans folks who haven't always known, who don't feel so secure, and so they don't tell their stories because they're scared of losing it.

there definitely are pre-realization trans folks who haven't always known, who will never figure it out on their own because they don't see themselves in stories. i was one.

additional theories:

- historically, trans folks needed to demonstrate absolute certainty in order to be given any medical treatment. "trapped in the wrong body" / "always knew" and such was indeed a requirement. this established bad cultural norms we're still stuck with.

- after folks transition, they look back on their lives for any signs that were there all along. it feels validating to identify them. people give themselves too charitable of a reading, producing insincere "always knew". (i'm probably sooo guilty of this, but idc!)

- people who haven't "always known" and in fact don't know yet are also less likely to even go looking for stories. so even if some people like me do write their "didn't always know" story, it won't reach the people who need to hear it.

@spiralganglion the only reason I stopped to think about it was because I stumbled on /r/egg_irl. then I realized I was spending an awful lot of time there. then I found “the pronoun playground” and went “oh, okay, so this is a capital-t Thing.” (watching “the owl house” for the first time right around this period was also eye-opening.)

like, I’d had one conversation with a friend about how it felt weird to be called “man” anything but ironically, and we’d mostly chalked it up to being young, but it turns out when you’re very loosely gendered / agender, yeah, sometimes it feels weird to be called a man! but other than that, I just didn’t think about it, so how could I have possibly “always known”?

after I went back and did some introspection I started thinking, “alright I guess that makes some more sense with this context.” but it definitely has not been a very clear-cut, “embracing who I am,” “this is something I always knew about myself and now I’m finally giving myself the freedom to live my truth” experience. it has actually mostly kinda sucked!

(of course all of this aligns pretty closely with my experience with autism so I’m 100% sure there is some overlap / alexithymia going on.)

anyway that’s probably too much info but I just wanted to let you know that you are not alone in having this all come as a realization rather than some kind of innate knowledge.

@nmott i really appreciate you sharing this!