do people ever mix traditional instruments with chiptunes or is that like watching a serious guy get dunked on by a muppet
@aeva What do you mean by “traditional”? There’s plenty of bands with guitars and chiptunes.
@bytex64 i don't have a precise definition, nor do i want to litigate one. keeping that in mind, i think acoustic guitars would absolutely fit most reasonable definitions of "traditional instrument", but the guitar is a funny case because it's had pretty much unbroken popularity over the past century or so, so it doesn't really sound out of place anywhere
@bytex64 whereas i think if you were to play the banjo or the hurdy gurdy with a square wave accompaniment people might reasonably assume you were being ironic
@aeva Hmm, yeah. Restricting it to unamplified instruments does eliminate everything I was thinking of. But surely someone has done that.

@aeva @bytex64 this feels like a thing that is impossible to figure out without trying. Like maybe it rules? or maybe it doesn't? I actually feel like specifically a hurdy gurdy could work

like it fits real well into dark sounding techno beats https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6msesBTcuNM so why not?

Hurdy-gurdy techno - Welcome from my studio vol.01

YouTube
@aeva @bytex64 anyways humans in general I think crave novelty in art (me. I crave novelty) so i think you should do this and report back
@halcy @bytex64 i don't have a hurdy gurdy or a banjo
@halcy @bytex64 nonjoke answer is i'm not trying to talk myself out of anything i'm just trying to explore the idea space and see what prior art exists to get a sense of what people have tried already and if i like it, but i can see how it comes off that way

@aeva @halcy @bytex64

the main problem you will have is sort of the same problem you get trying to blend acoustic instruments with distorted electric guitar. the guitars have an overwhelming amount of high frequency content and it's hard to hear anything else playing at the same time. unfiltered chiptune waveforms are even brighter. so you have to build your arrangements around dealing with that (folk metal is a good example)

@aeva @halcy @bytex64 not trying to discourage you, just warning you in advance about that, in case you try it and are like "why can't i hear the ____"
@cancel @halcy @bytex64 no this is the sort of information i'm looking for as i intuitively know that putting these things together isn't magically going to work on its own without some finessing and knowing the technical aspects is helpful
@cancel @halcy @bytex64 also i should clarify that i used "chiptunes" somewhat arbitrarily in that first post because that's one of the easier sounds to make with mollytime but i really just mean that most of the time i post something i made with mollytime there's at least one reaction comparing it to a retro console. "chiptunes" was a more concise thing to say
@aeva @bytex64 i saw a video while looking for the linked one titled „3d printed hurdy gurdy“. Disappointingly it was just a music box case. But.
@halcy @bytex64 i just remembered i do have a hurdy gurdy, it's a laser cut thing my wife built from a kit. it sounds like ass though so i don't think of it being a real one. i've also got a toy from teenage engineering that has medieval instrument samples loaded up on it