No one come off looking good in https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/07/us/politics/trump-iran-war.html, but let me point special attention to Gen. Caine. The quoted passage, below, shows precisely why "stay in your lane" is bad advice. When you're at a certain professional level, you shouldn't "stay in your lane"—context matters, and you're the one who knows the broader context and what it means. It's not reasonable to base your advice on broader considerations, it's mandatory.
@SteveBellovin Eyes open that you have given this more thought that I have, but: Do we want military leaders driving political decisions? How has that worked out when practiced elsewhere? It's a similar question to whether we want, say, real estate moguls with inherited wealth to misinterpret their exceptional privilege as evidence of competence in the areas of, say, politics, fiscal policy, environmental science, and law. Military people recognizing the limits of their expertise? Bravo.
@rose It's a tough balance!