Someone was asking how much garden to plant to feed three people. Let's do some calculations.

In my most productive year, I grew ½ gallons of dry beans on a 10 ft long trellis. A half gallon of dry beans weighs roughly 3.5 lbs.

You need roughly 60 lbs of dry beans per person to live off of for a year. From my garden efficacy numbers, that 60 lbs could be produced on 171.43 ft of trellis. For three people, that comes to 514.29 feet of trellis.

A more realistic diet would include a range of other crops, but you'd need the same order of magnitude of garden area.

A home garden is not the solution to food not being available.

However, if you have the time, resources, and land to grow a garden, it can supplement the nutrition you have in your diet while relying on farmers to meet your basic caloric needs.

@thebiologistisn in his books on self-sufficiency, John Seymour reckoned you could support a family of two for a year off a 1.2m x 6m deep bed. Which always felt a bit small. UK allotments are typically ~250 square meters (technically it's a ten rod plot, in weird units) and are supposed to be enough for a family of four.

@quixoticgeek The numbers will differ for different places. I'm at 45°N, with a fairly short growing season.

At my latitude, I have to organize my gardens by height along the south-north axis to prevent the taller ones from shading out the shorter ones. Where I grew up in the south, this was not a realistic concern.

Those growing further south can have multiple crops in rotation throughout the year. I mostly only have one crop for any given area of the garden (though I aim to improve this).

@thebiologistisn these numbers are based on the UK, so ~51°N.

To throw another data point in the works. I've done several years where I've been entirely self sufficient in salad for a single person, from some ice-cream tubs on a 1m long south facing window sill.

The reality is many crops are so cheap, self sufficiency isn't worth it. Potatoes, onions, dry beans. But using the same area for expert crops like raspberries and the like can be very cost effective.

@quixoticgeek @thebiologistisn I used to garden (double-dug beds, 5x5 feet), more for pleasure than anything else. I found I could grow herbs FAR cheaper than I could buy them (higher quality too, and I never had to harvest more than I needed at the moment). Vegetables, except sugar snap peas, were more expensive than retail, but I did grow some things (heirloom tomatoes, Swiss chard) I couldn't get at the grocery store. (Current home is surrounded by large oak trees.)