@fanksway Oh, there are absolutely two-faced people in this world.
The person I referenced, however, is not one. Her kindness is genuine. And she plays zero political games. She's not even in a position where playing politics would do her any good. She's just very good to have around.
The original thesis was that focusing on skills and ROI doesn't necessarily lead to having the best people. And I'm very much including "good manager" in the skills category. Lots of the people who climb through politics do so because people above them think they have certain valuable skills. Hell, one of the worst types of corporate political climbing is people who convince the technically naive above them that they have more skills and get more done than they actually do.