Can't stop thinking about the world building exercise/setup in Stephenson's Anathem where the "avout" (aka intelligentsia) were forced to live in gated monastic communities isolated to varying degrees (and by rank[1]) from secular society. This setup was decided on for a number of self-serving reasons (by the avout), but also largely imposed on them due to a long history where technology & academic pursuits led to several catastrophic events, incl. periodic civilizational collapses triggered by knowledge/research either being weaponized, irresponsibly commercialized and/or unleashed at a rate which society simply couldn't culturally/ethically/politically handle...

He (Stephenson) termed these events "Praxic crises" to emphasize that these kinds of disaster happen when purely theoretical insight is employed as real-world technology (praxis) without any restraint. In reality, there obviously isn't such a clear-cut separation between "purely theoretical knowledge" and its applications (POSIWID etc.) and that also forms part of the basis of this book's premise... I think we also very well know all the causes for such crises: From extreme short-term incentives (profit, war, perceived control/power), lack of ethical/philosophical grounding among decision makers (amplified by political power hierarchies), first-to-market pressures vs. deep understanding & balancing of impacts, but also severe lack of institutional regulation & memory (partially due to cyclic collapse and social amnesia)...

Food for thought...

[1] Monastic rank influenced degree of isolation: Unarians were allowed a few days outside each year, Decenarians every 10 years, Centenarians every 100 years, Millenarians only opened every 1000 years...

#Anathem #Stephenson #Technology #Science #Praxis #Collapse

@toxi It’s so cool to hear someone talking about my favorite book. I’ve actually never seen anyone else mention it so far. I practically hyperventilated while reading it, especially the second half. Sounds like now is a good time to reread it. Did you already finish it?
@thankfulmachine 🤩 Yeah, I read it around 2010, but also feel it's very much due for a revisit. It's been one of the books I found very hard to put down and inspiring on so many levels (Diamond Age being another fave). Also hard to stop thinking about in general long after reading (at least these parts of the plot, some other aspects also could have easily been culled IMO...)
@toxi I must nerd out with you then, lets not spoil it for anyone, but that book had one of the most elegant writing stunts I’ve ever read. Hopefully you remember what I mean 🙂
@thankfulmachine 🙌 Wow, that leaves quite a wide horizon of possibilities, doesn't it?! :) There were just so many great ideas/moments in this book... Any closer hints? Do you mean the parts about Plato vs. Pythagoreanism? Multiverse as DAGs? There were chapters in which I highlighted quotes on almost every page...
@toxi didn’t he also have it in the book that the avout themselves go a bit berserk past some tipping point and the catastrophes weren’t about them being endangered
@eesn Yeah, very much so! But all the politics and that last part of the book is a bit of blur in my memory (just so much happening), but will start re-reading... ask me again in a few months 😇