I just obtained the disc Endtroducing... (2005), which is the digital deluxe version of Endtroducing..... (1996). Now I have a conundrum about tagging it. I could tag disc 1 as Endtroducing..... (1996) and the second as Endtroducing... (2005), but they'd be shown as separate albums. I could use Endtroducing... (2005) for both, it's correct but feels wrong as the tracks on disc 1 are from 1996. I could have Endtroducing... for both but different years which is a mess.

#music #MusicBrainz

Endtroducing..... (1996) + Endtroducing... (2005)
Just Endtroducing... (2005)
Endtroducing... but 1996 for disc 1, 2005 disc 2
Something else?
Poll ends at .
@nicd They are separate discs, i.e. separate albums.

If you did not have a music file, they would be two physical discs/albums. You would accept it without much thought as you are now having.