This is what Weizenbaum wrote about the dawn of the computer age: it was used as an excuse to not even try to make society better. The same thing is happening with “AI” now.

We know what would make society better.

One example is UBI (which Weizenbaum mentions in the same book in passing as “negative income tax”).

But of course we don’t have universal healthcare or UBI nor really any other advances (perhaps the ADA was a rare win); instead trillions of dollars are invested into software that tells us to bomb schools; for the sole reason to say it was the computers’ fault, not ours.

This book* was written 50 years ago.

*Computer Power and Human Reason

#AI #society

“AI” is truly the ultimate expression (perhaps literally) of trying to solve social problems with technical solutions

#AI #society

“Pretending” might be a better verb than “trying” #AI #society
@thomasfuchs
I had dinner with him once. He schooled me on this point when I was at the height of my computer-aided-teaching phase. I was very dumb and he was very patient. I'm still grateful to him for that.
@thomasfuchs Not even close. The only problem ai is intended to solve is wages.

@thomasfuchs

Read that book in high school early 90's... I think it's like a GenX computer toucher bible

@thomasfuchs trying to find a copy of that book is a challenge. Used copies are going for close to a hundred and neither SF or Oakland libraries have it. IIL search shows that Whittier College might have a copy.

@thomasfuchs also, that encounter between Polanyi and Bukharin in the introduction!

The same thing has happened with science under Trump, but instead of the "Five Year Plan," it's whatever fluffs up Trump, the evangelicals, and the billionaires.