What is the ideal gaming experience for you?

Not what is a perfect game or anything but the experience of the game and the things you specifically enjoy there.

How well multi-player works.

If it is coop, like in Bubble Bobble(1986), that needs occaisional partner assists or straight-up player saves.

Or competitive, like Wipeout 2097(1996), which has excellent catchup mechanics.

Or larger scale competitive, like Quake1 shareware(Qtest) at 16-player.

Each of these showed examples of quality play-testing and balancing, making for enjoyable player interaction.