When you talk about people you make them important. I want to think more about who I choose to make important.

Even if you are criticizing someone, burying their bad ideas with logic and all the knives of science you're still making them and their ideas important.

You can expect me to talk about Iain M. Banks more and the questions I have about his work.

It's why it's probably is a good idea to do a critical review of Newitz and their "Terraformers" which I also have questions about.

I'm sick of criticizing people I don't like, you know. Let's argue about cool people instead.

@futurebird Ooh, OK. My starter. I think Iain M. Banks wrote slightly better books as Iain Banks, than Iain M. Banks. Controversial I know.

He wrote my favourite opening line of a book ever.

"It was the day my grandmother exploded"

@eclectech @futurebird I loved his books but I only read the ones with the "M." I liked Terraformers although I lean toward more gritty, hard scifi.

@Nonya_Bidniss @eclectech

Terraformers has a bit of the fever-dream about it.

Though, I just got to the bit about the dairy farm and I think Newitz has a sense of humor that is often lost on too many of their readers who either take it all seriously and think it's so cool... or so awful.

But the idea of a sentient cow having to be patient with a person who is fretting and feeling bad that the cow saw a dairy farm is objectively funny.

@futurebird @eclectech I think I get what you mean by fever-dream, for some reason I was never quite able to suspend my disbelief with the story so I didn't get absorbed into it. I like books I can imagine could be real in some future or alternate universe, it didn't quite do that. I think a lot of it was the characters, I just didn't imagine them being real.
@Nonya_Bidniss @futurebird @eclectech i really liked -terraformers- but plot threads left dangling all over the place. should have spawned a bunch of other stories set in the same universe but i don't think it did?