洪 民憙 (Hong Minhee) Mar 21

LLM coding assistants didn't create a split between craft-lovers and make-it-go developers. They revealed one that was always there.

For craft-lovers, what's being bypassed isn't the output but the act itself. Marx called this separation from the act of production. But the alienation isn't coming from the LLM. It's coming from a market that penalizes whoever produces output more slowly.

Why craft-lovers are losing their craft

Why craft-lovers are losing their craft

Les Orchard made a quiet observation recently that I haven't been able to shake. Before LLM coding assistants arrived, the split between developers was…

Hong Minhee on Things
Show thread洪 民憙 (Hong Minhee) 

LLM 코딩 어시스턴트는 소프트웨어 엔지니어들 사이의 分裂(분열)을 만든 게 아니다. 이미 있던 分裂(분열)을 드러낸 것이다.

匠人(장인) 氣質(기질)의 소프트웨어 엔지니어들이 느끼는 疎外(소외)의 源泉(원천)은 LLM이 아니다. 그들의 產出物(산출물)을 더 느리게 만드는 쪽에 不利益(불이익)을 주는 市場(시장)이다. Marx의 勞動(노동) 疎外論(소외론)으로 이 問題(문제)를 읽어보는 새 글을 썼다.

〈왜 코딩을 사랑하는 사람들이 코딩에서 밀려나는가〉 (한글)

Why craft-lovers are losing their craft

Les Orchard made a quiet observation recently that I haven't been able to shake. Before LLM coding assistants arrived, the split between developers was…

Hong Minhee on Things
Mar 21 at 9:33amWeb
Show thread洪 民憙 (Hong Minhee) Mar 21

LLMコーディングアシスタントはソフトウェアエンジニアたちの亀裂を作ったのではない。すでにあった亀裂を露わにしただけだ。

匠人気質のソフトウェアエンジニアたちが感じる疎外の源泉はLLMではなく、産出物を遅く出す側に不利益を与える市場にある。Marxの労働疎外論でこの問題を読む新しいエッセイを書いた。

「コーディングを愛する人たちが、なぜコーディングから追い出されているのか」

Why craft-lovers are losing their craft

Les Orchard made a quiet observation recently that I haven't been able to shake. Before LLM coding assistants arrived, the split between developers was…

Hong Minhee on Things