Jake in the desertI love songs by millionaires telling us we can't always get what we want, or that love is all we need
Dan Kletter 🥑@jake4480 ALL WE ARE SAYIN’…
Alison Wilder@jake4480 @soundclamp I rarely boost without alt text but more people should see this, lol
John Lennon was such a blatant hypocrite. As anyone who is that preachy usually is.
@alisynthesis @soundclamp ha! I should've alt texted, I usually do. Not usually with replies. Yeah, I liked Lennon as a kid, but later, became a Paul guy. Lennon had many issues. He later apologized for Jealous Guy, etc. I even read his books. But yeah. Super problematic.
The Other Brook@jake4480 @alisynthesis @soundclamp As a reasonably well-off kid from a dysfunctional family, Lennon is unfortunately more relatable to most people with the surplus cognition to call themselves Beatles fans than the three poor kids who were in the band with him. "Revolution" is such a radical statement in defense of not upsetting the status quo.
As I've gotten older I've found myself respecting George more than either John or Paul. Not that he didn't have his own bullshit (like, couldn't he have just murdered Eric Clapton and made the world a better place?) but he has a naked honesty in his work that they rarely, if ever, achieved.
@theotherbrook @jake4480 @soundclamp yeah I would pick George if I had to pick a Beatle.
But honestly, I would pick Ray Davies.
@theotherbrook @jake4480 @soundclamp they really were. Although the best best beatles were The Better Beatles
(I have no idea where I heard about this back in the day, but do NOT sleep on The Better Beatles.)
The Better Beatles - Mercy Beat 1981 (full album, 2007)
@jake4480 @theotherbrook @soundclamp yeah you're all welcome. the better beatles are CRAZY cool. I actually just looked them up for the first time, and they were about what you would think. I love punks.
@theotherbrook @jake4480 @soundclamp it is legitimately fun and cool music and I would choose to listen to these versions over the originals 9/10 times.
Beatles songs are mostly very child-like imo, and they somehow really work in this setting.
(I feel kinda like @theotherbrook about the Beatles. They're just way too much at this point.)
@alisynthesis @theotherbrook @soundclamp I mean, those Beatles influenced most every great artist after, though. Sabbath, Motorhead, Nirvana, Beck, the list goes on. THAT is my takeaway from it.
@jake4480 @theotherbrook @soundclamp truth. And the recordings were pretty much revolutionary. To me, that's the real legacy of the Beatles, not the songs so much.
@alisynthesis @jake4480 @soundclamp I wouldn't casually dismiss the songs either though. They did some incredibly great work, though at times John's feel like a put on and Paul's can be too mannered. But it's a much more consistent songwriting catalog than the Beach Boys who I love for many of the same reasons I love the Beatles.
Needless to say my relationship with The Beatles is complicated. But my bigger problem is with the role they've been assigned in the culture.
Sometimes I've tried to write about the first time I remember consciously listening to music. Bear with me as I try to do it briefly here...
@alisynthesis @jake4480 @soundclamp It was January 1971, I was four, and we'd just moved again. It was dark and snowy and we were driving into town down a street with more neon signs than I'd ever seen before, which says more about where I'd lived previously than it does about the city we were driving in.
The radio was on and everyone was silent, so I was listening to the song playing. Or was it more than one song? It was confusing. But I liked some of the words which sounded familiar, while others felt like they were those sorts of things adults would say that I didn't understand and they'd only wink and laugh when I asked them to explain them.
Then a new melody and new words started, which felt like they were speaking right to me. "Boy, you're going to carry that weight a long time..."
Paul was speaking to himself and the rest of the band with that one. They each knew that as great as it had been for a while to be a Beatle, the cultural burden placed on them was too much, too unrealistic, and too inescapable. It would be a long time before I understood that was what the words meant, but in that moment I learned the power of a good song to make us think it is talking to, and about, us. And no matter what I may think about the Beatles' legacy now, nothing can take that away from me.
@theotherbrook @alisynthesis @soundclamp carry that weight. YES. Amazing. That song.. its melody, just all of it. Once you've heard it once, it's WITH you. There's some magic going on there, of SOME kind.
@jake4480 @alisynthesis @soundclamp That was 55 years ago and it's never lost its grip on me. I said earlier that Paul was too mannered sometimes, but that doesn't mean he couldn't just reach into our chests and grab our hearts at times.
@theotherbrook @alisynthesis @soundclamp I'm huge on Paul as I said- was listening to Egypt Station just last week haha - it's actually my favorite of his solo stuff.. not counting Wings, probably, yknow, Band on the Run is tough to beat haha. But yeah obsessed with Got to Get You Into My Life, and also Big Barn Bed, which is like, one of my favorite things in the world. I listen to it constantly. I can listen to it on repeat (sometimes I do) 😂 Something about it. Someday I'll write a song close to as good as this, I hope. Y'all have probably even heard this, but, yknow. For posterity. And leaping armadillos. Yes
