sylThe FDA is taking public comments on a petition to create a federal registry of trans women
What the fuck?
dandeliondamn… this is clearly Antifa’s fault
It looks like this docket is closed for comments. I’m not sure where my comment went now.
It doesn’t help that this regulations site is awful.
__反いじめ戦隊
It's a trap!
Be sure to use a VPN if you will use this.
Marty Makary Slams Transgender Medical Industry, Demands Review
Dr. Marty Makary stepped up at a press conference and called out what he labeled the transgender-medical-industrial complex, arguing it has grown too fast and lacks basic accountability. The focus was on medical practices and commercial incentives that, in his view, push treatments on vulnerable young people without solid long-term evidence. This piece picks up...
What “category” should we choose?
Below is my comment so far, made without much thought (outside of trying to keep it clean & vaguely respectable) because this administration & its supporters have depressed me so much already that I just typed what first came to mind. Constructive input is welcome because I’m not trans (but dammit we’re ALL human beings deserving of respect and fair treatment), so I’m not sure if I’m screwing something up, or should be taking a less emotional approach for better effect. TIA.
When does the unjustifiable hate stop?! When do people stop interfering in the lives of others that have no effect upon their own? When does reason, logic, sanity, fairness, compassion, respect, etc start to matter to this administration? There is NO reasonable justification for this nonsense. There is more justification for making a registry for those hating people who are different from them because there is PLENTY of historical evidence demonstrating that THEY are the REAL threat to society.
I’m trans and I approve this message!
For category, i used drug administration, but idk if thats the best option
Thank you for the response! I’m glad I didn’t trip over myself in my rush to express what I was feeling while it was fresh in my head.
I’m gonna wait a day or two to make sure nobody else has any suggestions before I submit. I’ll post my final version if it changes in any significant way, & confirm submission when I do.
I’m strongly leaning toward including my actual name as an indication of how seriously I take this, but I’m not sure it’s worth the risk - both of tying it to my screenname (which goes back at least a quarter century for me on various sites), and the risk of inviting IRL retribution. I know it’s unlikely to make any real difference in what the assholes running things currently are likely to do, but I’d also rather not give them an easy excuse to be dismissive of my input. Any thoughts on that?
I had the same thoughts about them dismissing anonymous comments, and I included my full legal deadname for good measure. I definitely do not recommend doing that unless you are fully confident with it
They can’t help harassing trans folks. The fact that it’s for trans women only makes it even worse and non-sense
For easy access:
Read the petition: downloads.regulations.gov/…/attachment_2.pdf
Submit a comment: www.regulations.gov/…/FDA-2025-P-7321-0001
Article on the removal of warnings from HRT for menopausal cis women: fda.gov/…/hhs-advances-womens-health-removes-misl…
Anyone have a mirror link to the original petition? The official site is not working for me.
I’ve put it in one of my spare anon Google Drive accounts: …google.com/…/1XyO5qpghEV9NyiibF3Gjbh1Q29KvIB9h/
CorrectAliasThank you for posting this.
Do you not think that the first people put on the list will be the comments posted to their petition? Use a fake name and a VPN.
and this shit is why i’ve always contemplated DIY as an option
why Trump US is so much worse than russia
in 23 transphobic law relesed in russia nothing happened except surgeries(SRS, some doc’s still do orchi and ffs inside russia by just faking documents about surgery, some endos still do HRT) and gender marker post-law
who changed marker before law they HAVE offical hrt thru endos and even cannot change gender marker to AGAB (funny isn’t)
diy hrt is any pharmacy in every meter (i have 9+ pharmacies on one street in my city they are so close up to each other) any pharmacist will give estrogen, AAs
i still think russia pre-law and pre-20s years (without cencorship) was good country
in 23 transphobic law relesed in russia nothing happened except surgeries(SRS, some doc’s still do orchi and ffs inside russia by just faking documents about surgery, some endos still do HRT) and gender marker post-law
who changed marker before law they HAVE offical hrt thru endos and even cannot change gender marker to AGAB (funny isn’t)
diy hrt is any pharmacy in every meter (i have 9+ pharmacies on one street in my city they are so close up to each other) any pharmacist will give estrogen, AAs
i still think russia pre-law and pre-20s years (without cencorship) was good country
So i found this late and having read it obviously want to vomit.
What would be useful is to sus out all the authors they cite and ask them to submit their feedback; my assumption is the majority of the work has been twisted into propaganda by the authors of the petition.
Also, this is very obviously give an inch take a mile; they dont address the impact on gender dysphoria nor the low incidence of detrans and focus solely on suicide while ignoring the consternating social shit show we are expected to thrive in.
Every person listed and org in that document is an enemy of freedom.