Has there ever been a sustained backlash and doubt about a new big technology like what we are seeing with AI? Where the most vocal critics are tech people?

It's similar to bitcoin, to NFTs...

It's also similar to the internet-connected device trend, though I don't remember the resistance and doubt to that being as intense. I was mostly very excited about "the internet of things" I still put wifi in places where it doesn't belong with the most flimsy of excuses.

@futurebird I wonder if it’s useful to - additionally to other discussions - look at theAI backlash through the lens of previous new media panics, such as TV, the novel, or writing itself.

@slothrop

But it's not really a "new media form" it's a new production method.

@futurebird Yes! But some of the results are qualitative changes to accustomed forms of media. Recipe websites, for example, have become even more annoying than before AI. Everything is becoming more verbose, because it’s so easy to extract text (any text) from the slop machine.

Still, I’m with you that the main change is in how media are produced. I just think there’s a component of new media panics in some of the analysis, and we need to bear that in mind.

@futurebird I’m still holding out hope that when the AI bubble bursts, we’ll see a golden age for bug fixers and editors.
@slothrop @futurebird they rushed the technology out the door when it's wasn't ready for prime time, it just looks good enough that it could fool people who made technical decisions without having technical knowledge. The Practical applications of the technology as is are probably going to be so in the background that it wouldn't register as anything approaching the AI hype