timMar 13

RE: https://tooting.ch/@oscherler/116220880751078685

The core challenge here is actually that 1Password doesn't integrate natively into the passkey ecosystem, causing these unfortunate experiences.

Highly recommend you reach out to 1P as a customer and express these frustrations. It's been over 2 years and they still haven't shipped native support.

Show threadÖlbaumMar 13

@timcappalli At your saying that it’s 1Password that’s forcing Safari’s passkey dialogue to appear, even though the feature is turned off in Safari? How is that even possible?

I’m not gonna let them off the hook is that’s the case.

Show threadtimMar 13

@oscherler that isn't a Safari dialog, it is the macOS passkey UI, which always appears.

1Password is hijacking your browser session to show their in browser extension UI, which interrupts the macOS UI.

When 1Password integrates correctly, you'll see the 1Password in the macOS UI.

Here's an example with another credential manager (Strongbox in this case, instead of 1Password).

Show threadÖlbaumMar 13
@timcappalli I turned passkeys off in system settings, and I don’t have a passkey for this site saved
in Mac OS passwords.
Show threadtimMar 13
@oscherler You're not being offered anything in Apple Passwords, as it is disabled.
Show threadÖlbaumMar 13
@timcappalli It seems to me that you feel proud for being technically correct, but what you don’t realise is that the discrepancy between what I expect as a normal user when touring a feature off and your technically correct OS behaviour of not turning it off is part of the reasons a lot of people hate passkeys.
Show threadtimMar 13

@oscherler I hate this behavior too! Which is why I've spent almost 3 years pushing 1Password to make the appropriate change.

Unfortunately I can't force 1Password to do something.

Show threadÖlbaum
@timcappalli I’ll add my voice. Send them a nastygram. 😃
Mar 13 at 7:43pmWeb