there is a special place in hell for these scientists

https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/post/39484942

Blåhaj Lemmy - Choose Your Interface

Raises uncomfortable questions about consciousness. The only difference between these neurons and your own are the number of them and the structures they form. Of course it doesn’t know what it’s doing, but… Neither do our own neurons
Nueralink did pretty much the same thing to monkeys that are actually concision. So it this different only because those are human neurons? Is human consciousness different than animal consciousness?

I’m not sure this is quite analagous to neuralink’s monkey experiments. That said,

So is this different only because those are human neurons?

To my mind, a neuron is a neuron. The only difference between your brain and a monkey brain is, again, the number of neurons and the structures they form. I don’t see this as any different from monkey or rat or ant or entirely digital neurons.

I’m not sure this is quite analagous to neuralink’s monkey experiments.

Why not? It’s a chip reading inputs from neurons. This meme doesn’t make it clear if the chip was also stimulation neurons but Neuralink has plans for neural stimulation and it’s possible this was also tested on monkeys. So what’s the difference?

You seem to be arguing against a point that no one has made.
You seem not to understand what is being discussed here.
Correct. That was basically my point – I don’t think anything is being discussed, people are talking past each other.