I recommended The Fediverse over on Upscrolled

https://lemmy.world/post/43738745

Nice… I grabbed the picture of that post and am gong to share it with my friends that are getting tired of the big social media sites.

Thanks!

How’d it go over?

So far, only 4 upvotes, and two comments:

One telling me to add Misskey and Sharkey to the post, and the other one of the spam Gaza comments / posts.

I’d think that it would probably work better if more people posted posts about the Fediverse, than just me

Anyone who is on Reddit and UpScrolled will definitely enjoy Lemmy.

Idk, this was a comment left by u/chrismessina on the r/Fediverse version of this post:

I find their explanation for why they didn’t build on open social web protocols baffling:

Why isn’t UpScrolled a decentralized platform?

Because it doesn’t work for what we’re trying to build. UpScrolled isn’t decentralized (yet) because today’s open protocols (e.g., ActivityPub, AT Protocol) don’t reliably deliver what we need for a mainstream, video-forward app: fast global discovery, stable search/ranking, and smooth media. In practice, these stacks still lean on centralized indexing to work well, so we’re shipping the experience that works now-not a theory.

We keep things open and simple with lightweight, common-sense protections-spam/bot filtering, straightforward reporting, and consistent deletes when people remove their own content. We’re building interoperable by design (clean exports, stable APIs) and will add optional bridges to open protocols as they mature, so you can reach more people without sacrificing speed or simplicity.

(They’ve since scrubbed this from their FAQ).

bryan newbold (@bnewbold.net)

this is from the UpScrolled FAQ (upscrolled.com/en/faq/) I pretty strongly disagree! atproto works great for short-term video, with low latency and flexible discovery/feeds. dealing with raw video and CDN costs can be challenging, but no different from a proprietary system

Bluesky Social

We keep things open and simple with lightweight, common-sense protections-spam/bot filtering,

That is incredibly not-true. That platform is an absolute dumpster fire of spam and illegitimate content.