Sarah FackrellFeb 25
Today at the Seventh Circuit: Oral arguments in the Hague service case, Kangol LLC v. Hangzhou Chuanyue Silk Import & Export Co., Ltd., 25-02205:

RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:hvwhptk4oerwsuzau66ikwfy/post/3mageyvgssk24
Show threadSarah FackrellFeb 25
And the panel is: Kirsch, Jackson-Akiwumi, Pryor
Show threadSarah FackrellFeb 25
Kirsch was also on the panel last Friday:

RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:hvwhptk4oerwsuzau66ikwfy/post/3mfcegn2txs2b
Show threadSarah FackrellFeb 25
Overall impression: Much higher level of advocacy overall. Not sure how the court will rule. The judges asked quite a few questions about whether they'd create a circuit split if they ruled for Kangol. There were a fair number of detailed, pointed questions about the Hague Convention & FRCP 4.
Show threadSarah FackrellFeb 25
Oh, and yes, lots of questions about the new Coney Island decision.
Show threadSarah Fackrell
Side note: There are a lot of good potential #LawStudentNote topics in here.
Feb 25 at 5:29pmWeb
Show threadSarah FackrellFeb 25
Kangol really seemed to focus on the idea of waiver. The defendant engaged in settlement negotiations w/Kangol but defaulted in court. Kangol suggested that the defendant waived its arguments about personal jurisdiction and service because it didn't raise them in the settlement negotiations.