Lemmings, please give us your info dump.

https://mander.xyz/post/47816310

I did my dissertation on captive Asian elephants housed in a zoo and how it can influence their behaviour. Did you know that riding elephants is really bad for their back? And concrete floors can cause them to have arthritis in their feet? As well as other locomotion behavioural problems. Elephants are matriarchal and are one of the 5 animals believed to have the capacity for sentience. They are very intelligent and have various rituals they do as a herd. Elephant cows take care of the young but male elephants often leave the herd to live in small bachelore groups of other male elephants. Interestingly, cows that have not given birth will help to raise the calves of other female elephants. They share the responsibility.

Sadly a virus is plaguing elephants known as Elephant endotheliotropic herpesvirus though I did not cover that in my dissertation. I did not have a large sample size to monitor the behaviour and had to use another student’s data with theirs and the university’s permission due to extrenuating circumstances. I found that there were some areas of the enclosure (known as zones) that they preferred to avoid and theorized this could be due to the influence of visitors due to the proximity of viewing platforms at those zones. Of course there could also be other factors such as lack of food and hay nets in those areas, lack of enrichment, and since elephants are social they will do whatever the matriarch says most of the time. There were a few other things I found but that was the main thing and my supervisor agreed with me. Thankfully I passed my dissertation in the end. I had to repeat university a few times because of learning differences and autism but I got there in the end!

One of the 5 animals believed to have the capacity for sentience? I think you mean consciousness?

The entire mammal kingdom is widely considered sentient. As are many other groups like fish and insects.

Even with consciousness it’s stretching it to talk about just 5 species.

“Sentience has broader and narrower senses. In a broad sense, it refers to any capacity for conscious experience. […] In a narrower sense, it refers to the capacity to have valenced experiences: experiences that feel bad or feel good to the subject, such as experiences of pain and pleasure”.

Taken from academic.oup.com/book/57949/chapter/475703402

Also, here is an article about the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness that strongly supports the claim that sentience is a trait shared by most, if not all, of the animal kingdom.

animal-ethics.org/10th-anniversary-of-the-cambrid…

Afaik the terms are sentience vs sapience, which get constantly confused by everyone including me.

My brain came to a full stop here. One of those “have I ever seen these two in the same room” moments.

For anyone else like me: Sentience is the ability to feel and perceive things. Sentient is the adjective form.

Sapience is the ability to think and acquire wisdom, and the capacity for intelligence. Sapient is the adjective form.

Sentient is often misused for any living creature that thinks, when sapient would be the correct word.

Modern humans are classified as homo sapiens.

I think the confusion is summed up by a quote by a park ranger talking about the design of trash cans in National Parks: (paraphrased) There’s a lot of overlap between the smartest bear and the dumbest human.

So if I understand, both are sentient. But they vary widely on sapience.

Sentience is recognizing the trash can is there. Sapience is being able to figure out how to open the lid to access the trash and keeping the wisdom to open the next one easily. Sentience is feeling either frustrated or happy based on the level of success.

Unless I messed it up.

To quote Wikipedia:

Sentience is the ability to experience feelings and sensations. It may not necessarily imply higher cognitive functions such as awareness, reasoning, or complex thought processes.

So it just distinguishes animals of some neural complexity from primitive organisms. E.g. iirc jellyfish might not feel pain, and single-celled organisms most probably don’t.

Regarding sapience, many animals show some degree of intelligence, but we’re yet to see them reflecting on their own nature and experience. This I guess is what meant by sapience in the context of man vs other animals.