You can definitely have all your FEPs point to discussions here instead of socialhub. As prior examples of this go, iirc all of Evan P's FEPs point to his codeberg repo issue tracker, which is arguably more annoying than a federated forum.

@julian it could be interesting to add a like ?explain=true parameter to threads that can show like a modal dialog / banner explaining this post is federated and how you can interact with it from your existing fediverse account. Though I have noted sometimes mastodon fails to resolve NodeBB posts/thread URLs to AP representations and I don't know why nor how to fix it

julian

Co-Founder (NodeBB) | Husband 🤷‍♂️ and Dad 🙉 to three | Rock Climber 🧗‍♂️ | Foodie 🥙 | Conductor 🎵 | Saxophonist 🎷 ✅ Small teams craft better code. 🇨🇦 Made in Canada 🗨️ Federating NodeBB with funding from NLNet ♥️🇪🇺

⁂ ActivityPub.Space

@thisismissem would be good to know which URLs fail to resolve. It could be that NodeBB returned a 503 and that would lead to a failure in resolution. Just let me know next time it happens 😊

As for an intro banner, that's a neat idea. @[email protected] actually added something at the bottom of a topic, but it does make sense to add some AP specific text in the too.

@thisismissem I think that forum threads are great for open-ended conversations and bad for tracking tasks.
@evan that's a good point, different UX for different use cases!
@evan I say it's more annoying because it means yet another account people need to engage with your FEPs to give feedback.

@thisismissem I think that's part of the appeal! It's a separate service so it naturally gates participants.

On fedi it's more likely you'll encounter drive by criticisms.