Last night, I suggested switching to Signal in my family group text

https://lemmy.world/post/42566759

Last night, I suggested switching to Signal in my family group text - Lemmy.World

This morning, my entire family either switched or said they already had a Signal account. Now we have a family Signal chat. I expected resistance, not compliance! I’m very happy.

My friends and I would love to switch to Signal but every time we try it we just find that the app isn’t very nice to use and a lot of functionality we have come to take for granted is missing. Has it improved recently or is that still the case?
What… What sort of functionality? I struggle to think of something it lacks as a messaging app…

Here’s a list I made last time I tried it. Might not all still be true!

  • Signal accounts are tied to a phone number, which is dumb and limiting. You can’t contact someone by username only (or let someone contact you without giving them your phone number), nor can you have multiple phone numbers (I have a work phone and personal phone).
  • Signal has no polls or pinned messages.
  • No cloud chats comes with a few disadvantages e.g. no global search across all chat history.
  • No cloud media storage means you only can keep as much as you can fit on your device, whereas in telegram i can still look at pictures sent to me a decade ago.
  • No bot api, which most people probably don’t care about but sucks for me cos I regularly make telegram bots to improve my experience and for fun.
  • Signal also has no custom themes but that’s kinda meh.
  • Signal has no silent or scheduled messages, and editing/deleting a messages is time-limited (and beta).
  • Pretty sure telegram has better emoji reactions and animated gifs etc though not sure.
You’re wrong on all these points that matter.
Please elaborate
Im fairly certain you don’t have to share your phone number with someone to contact them, just your username - Isnt that the while point of the username?
Yeah. And you can pin messages, have pills, edit messages and schedule send.