This is the guy who directed the Melania movie
This is the guy who directed the Melania movie
Like everything on Wikipedia, it’s a communal thing that’s decided by consensus based on preference and guidelines. In this case, here are reasons why the image wouldn’t be selected over the existing one:
For a living person, the considerations are mostly what you’d expect for any other application, namely: is the copyright compatible? is it neutral? does it capture the subject well? is it well-composed? it it high-resolution? since the subject is alive, is it fairly recent in order to capture how they look now? does it capture how the subject typically looks and/or something the subject is known for? Here’s what the Manual of Style has to say on image selection broadly.
The lighting in the OP is much worse than in the current image and even gives the subject red-eye.
Is there a rule against using filtered images? A red-eye filter is trivial, but it would still be a filter. But I think even most cameras do this automatically in portrait mode.
Is there a rule against using filtered images?
No,* although I was referring to why the image as-is wouldn’t be used. Images sometimes undergo minor editing for things like color correction, watermark removal, etc. It’d be preferable if the original image didn’t have the red eye, but the correction isn’t a huge deal. The poor lighting is the much more severe issue.
* There are different levels of “rules” on the English Wikipedia. I’d categorize them into “policies with legal considerations”, policies, guidelines, the Manual of Style, and norms.
At random:
I actually can’t speak to Reich’s experience, as I hadn’t heard about this before; the only information I could find on it is this Reddit post which states somebody tried to upload his incompatibly licensed photo from IMDb. The citation in this image is to a members-only Game Changer video.
The steps are straightforward and should go as follows:
So to your question: I can’t really say, because it doesn’t seem like a difficult process, and I don’t know how/if Sam Reich’s experience deviated from it.
I was thinking his imdb profile could use a refresh.
Did we get any pictures of him with Weinstein on the island?