Sine_Fine_BelliThe queer people who are buying guns to prepare for Trump’s America
At some point it just becomes “try to only point your security blanket at yourself, I guess” levels of helplessness.
But to anyone considering buying a gun:
Owing a firearm makes you (as of 2020) 8-35x more likely to kill yourself with it med.stanford.edu/…/handgun-ownership-associated-w…. And considering this is a purchase during a… let’s just say “immensely stressful” period… yeah.
But also… what purpose does it serve? A single ice nazi comes knocking on your door, you spot them through the peephole, and have time to grab your gun, load it, and fire through the door? Then… you flee Everything in the hopes that the cops don’t decide to label you a “cop killer” on top of that?
This is why gun nuts make their entire lives built around “systems” to always carry a gun and be able to quick draw. Because the reality is… whoever shoots somewhat accurately first probably “wins”. Which leads to “Well… maybe that phone in their pocket they weren’t even reaching for is a gun. I am legally justified”
But that also basically works for only the first few people to try it. Everyone else gets a squad of ice nazis either kicking down the door and flashbanging them (and themselves) or just unloading on the house from the curb.
I realize the world is scary. I am scared shitless more often than not. But think through what buying a gun can even accomplish versus all the risks.
And maybe consider reaching out to your local community organizers to figure out what CAN be accomplished.
I don’t imagine one person protecting themselves from ICE with a gun, but I’d kinda like to see some local armed militias prevent ICE from terrorizing people.
Like I said: Even an organized and well trained militia are pretty much useless against a modern military. Police departments around the country have armored vehicles for these situations and any militia that gets too “uppity” is begging for a drone strike… or even just a mortar.
But yes. Individuals can’t do anything. We only have strength when we work together and look out for each other. An individual buying a gun to “protect themselves” isn’t gonna do shit and is mostly just going to escalate things rapidly. Whereas a community protecting themselves, with firearms or otherwise, can at least buy time.
But that requires coordination and a LOT of focus on “optics”. Again, The Black Panthers are historically one of the best examples of this. Yes, they have guns and do armed patrols. But mostly it is about community service and outreach so that killing one Black Panther means you are accepting the murder of that entire community. That isn’t going to stop things once things accelerate to a full blown civil war (just look at Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan for what the US military will gladly do to a village…) but it DOES buy time.
But Americans have this mindset that just buying a gun turns you into John McClane and you are going to single handedly solve all the worlds problems in three respawns or less.
Even an organized and well trained militia are pretty much useless against a modern military.
Just going to ignore all the times modern militaries have lost to insurgent groups?
In skirmishes? Sure.
In terms of wars? Not so much.
The quintessential example is the US (and USSR before us) in Afghanistan. Yes, the Taliban and the Brave Mujaheddin Fighters ™. And… hit and run tactics… sort of worked. Moreso against the USSR where those militias were being armed by a different military superpower… and where the USSR troops were already behind the curve gear wise. Against the US? It is less that the Taliban et al “won” and more that we lost. We were bled out during an unpopular war where we had no meaningful objectives and no desire to actually fight and kind of just… left.
You aren’t going to bleed out the US Military to the point that they and the christofacists leave the continental US (or even Hawaii… Alaska we would sell to putin in a heartbeat). Instead, you are going to see something a lot closer to the nazi occupation of Western Europe where you just have mass punitive executions until people turn on the guerillas.
We aren’t at the point of pitched battles. People are calling for resistance.
And of we do end up at all out war with the government, the military will likely shatter and be considerably less effective than the military that couldn’t defeat the Taliban.
And do you think this would be a popular war? Fairly certain it would be less popular than any war the US ever fought including the US civil war. That at least had a purpose a reasonable number of people supported.
Which is a very different topic than “Just going to ignore all the times modern militaries have lost to insurgent groups”
But sure, let’s address your new argument while ignoring the old one:
People are calling for resistance.
Yes. And we need to understand what resistance is going to make a difference. One person owning a gun to protect themselves… isn’t even going to accomplish the stated goal. A well trained militia… ignoring the fact that getting one of those takes a lot more time than we have, is also going to be of very questionable value once the civil war goes hot.
But going to protests and speaking to the community organizers and figuring out how to protect each other? THAT is proving incredibly effective… at least for this phase.
And of we do end up at all out war with the government, the military will likely shatter
Having spent years having to work with military folk and officers… I doubt it. That is an entire org built around “just following orders” and “being apolitical because I serve the office, not the man”. Yes, people will bitch and moan. But they’ll get told “It doesn’t matter if you agree or disagree with the war. What matters is that you look out for the man in the trench next to you”. And once the bullets start coming back, they will gladly hose down however many protesters or militia soldiers they can because “it is them or us”.
be considerably less effective than the military that couldn’t defeat the Taliban.
Again, the Taliban did not defeat the military. The US government did. In fact, in most skirmishes (that weren’t just ambushes and IEDs), we massacred them.
Because, “victory” in that case is convincing the christofacists to leave “their country”. Which is the exact same reason the taliban just stuck around, waited for the coalition to leave, and went back to oppressing people.
But this also has the added factor that we already see with fuckface: It won’t take too many massacres by the military before the soldiers that we thank for their service realize they will be massacred if they lose.
The only way a civil war goes beyond “We put down isolated groups of terrorists” is if the military (whatever branches) tends to align with different forks of the government. I… am not optimistic with that and suspect any isolated bases deciding to not support the christofacists will realize how quickly they run out of supplies. But it could happen.
The militias will, at best, be cannon fodder to stand in trenches. Which… is what we see in Ukraine. Trained soldiers can engage in maneuver combat and take ground. Conscripts/militia can get given a gun, pointed in a general direction, and try to prevent those maneuvers from working. But a well equipped combat force is still going to steamroll over them.
We’ve seen already instances where ICE has backed down when there was some actual resistance
And we have seen instances where the ice nazis murder first and fabricate an excuse later.
If they think someone in an apartment has a gun, they aren’t going to run away. They are going to just shoot. What makes ice back off is when the community stands up and makes it clear that they are going to have to murder a LOT of people to get what they want… and that works for now.
Which is why fuckface is working so hard to get the us military to “support” ice. They are actually trained for this and will just chuck some grenades into that apartment.
You’re entire argument is they’re killing us already, we really don’t need to give them another reason…
You prepare now, when you can still buy arms, not after when you have had that right and other rights taken away.
That is my position. It would be cool if peaceful protest succeeds at reforming the nation, but I don’t think it would happen. In such a situation, having the resources and accepting the possibility of violence would go a long way towards saving the lives of innocents.
If it turns out peace works, I would gladly end my gun range subscription and abandon social media. I want to spend my time with anime girls, not the bullshit that Trump and his kind are flinging around.
But you’re suggesting that we… don’t arm ourselves, and that we should just stand by and let them kill us…make up your mind
No, I am saying that being armed and predisposed to peace go together. It gives people the option to fight if it becomes necessary. The Black Panthers are the way.
Exactly.
All the gun nuts leap at the idea that they can grab a rifle and fix the world. And they shit on the actual legacy of The Black Panthers by distilling them down to that.
The vast majority of what made/makes The Black Panthers effective is that they focus so much on community outreach. Far more time is spent getting to know the neighbors and families than sending bullets downrange. All because the goal is to NOT fire a shot. Because the shitbags understand… if you shoot Jamal then you are going to be attacked by multiple city blocks worth of people who can personally talk about how Jamal helped make sure their kids got home safe or literally just gave them a chance to talk through their pains and worries
Instead, all the gun nuts are leaping at the chance to justify buying a new optic or buying a third ar-15. And… there is definitely a lot of “Wow. Even the Libertarians think we should abolish ICE” going on.
Like maybe a year ago American’s taking pot shots at ICE might have spooked them back into their basements. But now ICE has galvanized a culture of general oppression. They’re just itching to Tiananmen an entire peaceful protest.
Eh. I think they would still shit themselves if they started wondering what those whizzing and popping noises were.
But it would basically work “once”. Then they would just assume any mass of protesters were black kids with toy trains and unload with their ar-15s. And every single “raid” would become a no knock where they just sneak up and kick down the door and flashbang and shoot at any kids they see while “getting their man”. Because now they are up against an army of terrorists.
A Lemmy user trying to encourage people not to buy guns to protect themselves? Simping with maga?
Buy a gun (or even a replica) and train with it. Just being familiar handling a firearm will drastically increase your effectiveness should you find yourself in a situation using a gun.
Just having a gun and not training with it will only introduce an element of lethality into your life that previously wasn’t there.
How to Train When There is No Ammo
Ok so what’s your advice? If you’re just here to convince ppl not to arm themselves you’ve gotta have a better option?
Complying their way into a camp seems to be this coward’s plan.
And maybe consider reaching out to your local community organizers to figure out what CAN be accomplished.
That is my advice and it always is that.
Individuals cannot do anything no matter how high your killstream was in Call of Duty last week.
Communities… can’t do as much as we would like but it is about strength in numbers and protecting your fellow human being. And community organizers ARE the people working on this.
But people get pissy when you tell them that they aren’t going to solve everything by buying a PSA rifle and maybe going to the shooting range a few times a year.
As for what that kind of resistance is? Maybe don’t talk about that on public facing social media?
911 is a joke and there’s a non-zero chance they’ll kill you if you get the wrong officer and you don’t satisfy their favored supremacist purity criteria. I’d rather be armed and not outsource my safety to someone I cannot trust. I also trust myself to resolve situations in my home with better judgement than a person who more than likely joined the police to live out their violent power fantasies.
I’m having a hard time taking you seriously when you’re discouraging organizing. 2A oriented groups are legitimate forms of organization and have a role to play. This isn’t about becoming an army that will fight the military, it’s about providing security when the state can no longer be trusted to do so and serving as a disincentive to right-wing paramilitary groups.
You’ve got this mixed messaging saying “the real resistance is talking” but alluding to “things beyond that” presumably organized direct action or civil disobedience. Why can’t a 2A group do both of those things?
“Individuals cannot do anything” The way you’ve framed this encourages apathy and the role we all have to play in any organized movement. Rather, we’re all individuals and we all have a duty to do something. When ‘individuals’ work together with common interest that is the very definition of ‘community’.
How long have you been hanging out with the military folk and officers you mentioned in this thread? I wonder if your harsh judgement of the means others which to assemble and express their rights is being influenced by overexposure to pig-headed thought.
chosensilencepeople need to arm themselves to protect each other in the moment, not as some grand attempt at a revolution. nobody thinks Americans would win against the military through battles alone, but 200 armed citizens against 50 ICE nazis would be better odds at saving someone during a protest or demonstration or kidnapping.
we have to be willing to suffer consequences if we truly want to protect each other.
If there’s a protest with 200 people openly armed and standing in ranks, I imagine it would keep the 50 ICE clerks far enough back that they couldn’t kick old ladies or shove photographers. I also imagine they would quickly call it an illegal demonstration and bust out the tear gas.
If there’s a protest with 200 people scattered through the crowd with concealed handguns, it’s not going to change ICE tactics at all.
we have a history of armed protests in this country and they have never escalated into confrontation. the black panthers marched armed and were left alone. i know that doesn’t mean it’ll be that way always but it is a tactic that has worked well. the problem is yes, fascists use resistance as evidence of violence and the need to control their opposition, but resistance is still the answer. nothing will do will be innocent enough to be ignored. we will never win by ceding any ground.
ClassStruggleThen kindly stay out of the way of those that do carry.
Not to diminish your comment, but this research is tautologically flawed:
Men who owned handguns were eight times more likely than men who didn’t to die of self-inflicted gunshot wounds. Women who owned handguns were more than 35 times more likely than women who didn’t to kill themselves with a gun
I mean… obviously? I bet sailors get bit by sharks more than Great Plains farmers. This is the wrong denominator — they should be looking at all cause mortality and all types of suicide in gun owners vs others.
I definitely do believe owning a gun would have a higher suicide rate by making it more convenient to use the gun in a moment of weakness/impulse.
That article brutalizes the original research for a scarier popping headline.
From the actual paper, the important bit:
Rates of suicide by any method were higher among handgun owners, with an adjusted hazard ratio of 3.34 for all male owners as compared with male nonowners (95% confidence interval [CI], 3.13 to 3.56) and 7.16 for female owners as compared with female nonowners (95% CI, 6.22 to 8.24).
Handgun owners did not have higher rates of suicide by other methods or higher all-cause mortality. The risk of suicide by firearm among handgun owners peaked immediately after the first acquisition, but 52% of all suicides by firearm among handgun owners occurred more than 1 year after acquisition.
This is the interesting bit for me. If you remove people buying a gun for purpose of suicide, all cause mortality is the same, which indicates that purchase of a gun for suicide is a relatively small proportion of all gun owners.
Also important to note: this type of statistic does not differentiate no difference from not enough data to say there’s a difference, which is important. P value/frequentist statistics cannot say no effect, ever.
A firearm is not a good solution to anything. It’s a tool of last resort. If i believe I, or some one I love is going to die. At that point, i don’t care if i can beat the military, or if im labeled a cop killer because the alternative is Im dead. This isn’t about being a hero, this isn’t about saving my neighborhood or my country, this isn’t about beating the military. Owning and carrying a firearm is about giving yourself one last option when all else fails. When you know you will die without it, may as well have the chance to do something.
Firearms also work as a deterrent. They are a show of force. Without it, the government has a monopoly on violence. Cops, ICE, the military, whoever. When they are they only ones with the ability to do that, we will always be under their thumb.
I’m not saying we should be resorting to violence unless there is absolutely no other choice. The very last thing i want is a shootout or fight with any government agency. I will not win that fight. But I would rather die standing and fighting then die on my knees.
I strongly believe that it is everyone’s responsibility to do their best to protect themselves and those they love. Go exercise. Go learn martial arts. go learn how to shoot. Not because you plan to use violence, but so when violence is used on you, you are not helpless.
I’m not going to point out the flaws in your statistics. Someone else already did that.
Don’t shoot through the door.
4 rules of gun safety
Cringe. Bootlicker
Terrible take, cringe
One of the worst takes ever in the history of bad takes ever. A truly terrible take
At this point, if your state reps are still driven to make more gun laws, they’re not helping. They are ensuring that maga is grandfathered in to gun ownership while the people looking to become gun owners this year are pushed back.
All modern gun control came from a fear of the Black Panthers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mulford_Act
Reagan started fucking us over well before he became president.
Yup, most gun laws restrict ownership and usage by POC more often than a white person.
This queer socialist has been armed up for 30 years.
If you’re currently versed in Firearms and are able to start a chapter, or if you are lucky enough to live in an area with a local chapter the SRA is a good organization. https://socialistra.org/
Good basis of organized tactics. The guide below is more about organized movement than direct fire. Below will NOT help you in a firefight as it relies on a much larger trained force than you are likely to have. Good to know what the bastards study though. https://www.trngcmd.marines.mil/Portals/207/Docs/TBS/B2F2837%20Rifle%20Squad%20Tactics.pdf?ver=2015-05-27-100939-710
How to avoid getting balled up and kettled. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/anarch-ish-how-to-win-at-kettling-a-guide-for-non-policemen
Sabotage guide from WW2 https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/26184.txt.utf-8
General armed defense https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/organizing-armed-defense-in-america
How to organize a rapid response from a very high level with further details resources. https://southerncoalition.org/resources/rapid-response-101/
Good general advice on organizing, also a good resource to find groups near you that are accessible. https://www.fiftyfifty.one/organizer-resources
Feel free to reach out for any other resources.
www.blazingsword.org is better for LGBTQ+
SRA unfortunately has a ton of tankies…
FerrousYou’re joking right? The subreddit is heavily tankie and the forums before they took them offline where also tankie. I’m sure there are some people who aren’t like that, that are members of the SRA, but the majority is super tankie. Just look at their mission statement, it’s even got anti-capitalist as part of their mission.
No, why would I be joking? What’s the joke? Seriously, can we dive into this? What about my comment made you think I was trying to be funny?
subreddit
forum
You’re basing your opinion of a leftist org entirely on your personal internet experiences. Basing your opinion of an organization on internet experiences is not wise.
Just look at their mission statement, it’s even got anti-capitalist as part of their mission.
If you think being anti capitalist is synonymous with being a tankie, then you’ve done a better job discrediting yourself than I ever could have.
The SRA takes great pains to communicate the idea that they are a broad coalition of queen folks, people of color, anarchists, marxists, maoists, marxist-leninists, etc… united in the belief of anti capitalism. Their whole shtick is that any and all leftists can join united under the idea of learning about guns - regardless of individual philosophy. The fact that youre lobbing around the word “tankie” at zero hour of the fascist descent, in combination with equating “tankie” with anticapitalism, in combination with spewing FUD about one of the most successful and inclusive leftists gun rights orgs, makes it pretty clear that youre just one of the typical radlibs who aren’t ready to commit to reckoning with the United States’ burgeoning fascism.
Thanks for proving my point… nothing like an .ml tankie to come swooping in and drop some hot ass garbage.
PS. You can go through my comments, I’m a hardcore 2a guy who’s volunteered time with the pink pistols via my firearms and my own range, before blazing sword and they combined. The fact that you’re acting like those of us who don’t like fascist in any form are ok with swapping right wing fascist with you tankies version of authoritarianism is just hilarious.
Radlib lol first time I’ve heard that one.
Shiiiiiiiit I did not know, I’ll update my post. Thank you for the info.
You’re good, a lot of people don’t know it is. This is why I volunteer my range for blazing sword vs the SRA.
Nah, I’m well. You’re good. You’re helping make marginilized people safer.Thank you.
I’ll also recommend the John brown club
On a more practical “where can I buy a gun” level, www.gunbroker.com is basically ebay for guns, serves the whole USA, and has been very reliable for me over the years. The catch is the guns are not mailed directly to buyers, a local gun store acts as middleman to receive and you go pick up from there. Saves a lot of time and money if you know what you’re looking for.
For knowing the law in your state about you can and can’t own and carry, start here:
Please visit the shop you’re shipping the gun to as they usually have a nominal fee for taking delivery of and storing the weapon until you can pick it up, or until you pass any needed background check.
FoniI understand it as an individual decision, but on a social level…damn, this isn’t the path to a healthy society.
samus12345We’re past the point of any chance of being in a healthy society, unfortunately. Best we can hope for is a healthy society rising from the ashes of this one.
What also isn’t part of a healthy society is feeling like if you’re next, wondering if your neighbors are okay, questioning why there are armed masked men outside of your kid’s school.
I am trying to not engage with the gun nuts but I just want to point out:
What also isn’t part of a healthy society is feeling like if you’re next, wondering if your neighbors are okay, questioning why there are armed masked men outside of your kid’s school.
Actually, I would argue all of those are a part of a healthy society. Because all of that is you being part of a community. You don’t decide “Nobody else is safe but I am going to be”. You actually question if the people living near you or your co-workers are struggling. And you wonder how you can make things better.
No. Living under a christofacist regime is not healthy. But nobody is going to be able to protect themselves when the shit hits the fan. We have constant evidence of that.
But people CAN protect their friends and neighbors. Individually we are weak. As a collective we are strong. And if folk would put even a fraction of the effort they put in to kitting out their PSAs into actually checking in with that neighbor to see how they are doing…
You can do both. However you express your rights, I support you. Community builds Solidarity which is our greatest weapon. Ammosexuals are fucking annoying little boot licking chuds. But not every person that is armed means you any ill will.
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/j-clark-three-way-fight
