Hello instance members! A question from your friend local admin team here (@andrew and @leigh) about updates to this instance.

As some of you have probably noticed, we're still on version 4.2 of Mastodon, because that's the most recently-released version of the "Hometown" Mastodon fork that we're currently running. Unfortunately, the fork hasn't seen updates recently, and I don't see that changing soon.

As such, I wanted to check with folks here on the instance about what y'all would prefer as the path forward! I think we have a few options:

1. Keep running Hometown, and wait for an update. Upside: very little change in your day-to-day, downside: no new features (like quote posts), security updates require manual work from the admin team.

2. Switch back to the mainline Mastodon software. Upside: reasonably easy to do, we track upstream so security and feature updates are easy. Downside: no local-only post option, a few other smaller features / changes from Hometown also go away.

3. Switch to a different Mastodon fork (e.g. the glitch fork). Upside: keep local posts, along with newer Mastodon features. Downside: the most technically difficult migration (which will also almost certainly require extended downtime), we'd still be on a fork of Mastodon with no guarantee of ongoing maintenance.

4. Something else I haven't thought of!

(also if we do option 2, we'd need to decide what to do with local-only posts; I could delete them, change the visibility on them, or something else entirely)

I'm going to open this up to everyone here as a poll, open for a week. I'll probably re-run the same poll later to make sure we don't miss anyone, too. Please feel free to leave comments, suggestions, and more in the replies here.

Keep running Hometown
20%
Switch to mainline Mastodon
80%
Switch to another Mastodon fork
0%
Something else!
0%
Poll ended at .
@OttawaPlaceAdmin voted but I’d support whatever you decide. Really appreciate the work that goes into this. Thanks! @andrew @leigh
@auxonic @OttawaPlaceAdmin @andrew @leigh I'm with Eric. The questions are beyond my competency to make an educated vote.
@dairpo @auxonic @andrew @leigh Really the question is: how much would you want or care about having local-only posts? If most people don’t care that’s also useful to know.
@OttawaPlaceAdmin @dairpo @andrew @leigh local only posts are low value for me. I’d suggest converting them to private in a migration.

@OttawaPlaceAdmin
I'm good with whatever you decide. I don't maintain it and don't know how much work it is and I'm grateful you do what you do. I don't have any right to burden you with my garbage opinion.

As for local only posts, I've never seen a reason to use them. And my mobile client doesn't seem to have it as an option since i was going to set the scope to local only. Oh well.
@dairpo @auxonic @andrew @leigh

@OttawaPlaceAdmin
But, i voted since you weren't actually looking for dissertations and lengthy explanations.
@dairpo @auxonic @andrew @leigh
@OttawaPlaceAdmin @dairpo @auxonic @andrew @leigh I like local only posts since I have another mastodon account and I figured this one would be for local stuff, but I supposed hashtags accomplish the same thing.
@antonio106 @OttawaPlaceAdmin @dairpo @auxonic @leigh The local feed (which contains posts from users on this server, and isn’t going anywhere–sorry for the confusion!) is definitely better for finding local stuff, as are hashtags. Local-only posts are (IMO) less useful for discovery.
@andrew @OttawaPlaceAdmin @dairpo @auxonic @leigh ah ok. In that case...what's the use-case for a "local only" post? Unless it was a private intranet walled garden type thing.

@antonio106 @OttawaPlaceAdmin @dairpo @auxonic @leigh Yeah, the intent from Hometown was to allow people to post publicly for anyone on the same instance, but only for that instance. Local-only public posts are only visible if you have an account on the server, not other servers or from e.g. search engines. I tend to use it for stuff like welcome posts, mostly.

IIRC the author of the Hometown fork runs a server for an extended group of friends/acquaintances, where being able to post something publicly only among the group makes a lot of sense.

@andrew @OttawaPlaceAdmin @dairpo @auxonic @leigh see that makes sense then. If it was for my extended kin or an office. But otherwise so long as I can *see* the local feed I don't care and change my vote. 😋