How AI broke the smart home in 2025

https://lemmy.world/post/40624765

How AI broke the smart home in 2025 - Lemmy.World

Lemmy

If anyone wants privacy while maintaing a smart home, then Home Assistant is the solution.
Its not adopted widely because it has a learning curve and it needs a bit (or a lot) poking around to make it work.
It also has a voice assistant that is not AI powered ( but it could be supplemented by a local LLM if you really want to).
A big rabit hole if anyone is interested to go to.

It’s not adopted widely because every single smart home device marketed to normies is infected with cloud bullshit. Go to Home Depot or whatever and look on the shelf: literally every single product will have “Works with Alexa,” “Works with Google Home,” and/or “Works with Apple HomeKit” badges stamped all over the package, but not a single one will mention a damn thing about Home Assistant even when the device actually is compatible. The closest you get is ones that mention “Matter” 'cause it’s at least supposed to be a standard, but it feels like it’s getting slow-walked harder than CableCard sometimes (and if you don’t remember how that worked out, the answer is “not well”).

I would almost call it a conspiracy against openness, but it’s really just the banal result of no rent-seeking leading to no excess profit to plow back into marketing… which is even worse.

Once you get it setup, start looking for homeassistant compatible hardware instead. There is a lot. Even some big brands use protocols (zigbee, zwave, matter) that can connect to homeassistant without a need for their hub (granted you do have a HA hub) or cloud connection.

I try to stay away from WiFi if possible, but if home assistant compatible I’ll use it.

There’s a lot of stuff that can work with Home Assistant, but it’s essentially never listed as a feature on the package, so normal people will never know it’s an option.

That’s the problem – the lack of marketing – not any lack of functionality on Home Assistant’s part.