Atypical tool and object use in wild immature chimpanzees reveals developmental pathways to innovation - Scientific Reports

Innovation drives cultural evolution, yet little is known about its developmental origins or the role of immature individuals in generating novel behaviors. We examined 67 object uses by 36 infant and juvenile chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii), over 15 months at Ngogo, Uganda. Nearly half of object uses were atypical, deviating from adult norms. 94% of atypical bouts were novel additions or modifications of adult forms or uses in new contexts, including three efficacious innovations: doll play, moss-sponging, and leaf-clipping to request carrying. To assess individual differences, we developed an Exploration Index integrating frequency, diversity, and atypicality of object use. Nine individuals had notably higher scores. Females and offspring of multiparous mothers scored higher, indicating effects of sex and possible social scaffolding from experienced mothers and siblings on object use. These findings suggest that immatures generate novelty at the margins of species-typical behavior yet vary in their propensity to innovate. A permissive social environment for object play may be key to the developmental pathways of innovation, providing a generative context for behavioral variation on which social learning and selection can act. If retained and transmitted, even rare innovations by immatures could contribute to the accumulation of cultural complexity.